Supreme Commander 2 Review

In Standardizing Its Approach, Gas Powered’s Sequel Sacrifices Its Identity
by Adam Biessener on Mar 02, 2010 at 05:31 AM
Reviewed on PC
Also on Xbox 360
Publisher Square Enix
Developer Square Enix
Rating Rating Pending

Supreme Commander 2 suffers from an identity crisis. The first game threw out the real-time strategy rulebook and forged in a bold new direction with a smooth income/expenditure economic model and maps so huge you could literally nuke an entire base and only put a dent in your opponent’s overall war effort. It made some missteps along the way, but fixed many of them – most notably the unfortunate interface – in the Forged Alliance expansion. Developer Gas Powered Games has since shied away from some of its unique aspects while attempting to retain the game’s core concept of building huge robot armies and watching them blow each other up. While that central amusement factor is still there, and I deeply appreciate the extensive unit rework, much of the strategic overlay that made the original compelling has gone out the window in favor of a more standard approach.

The monstrous scale of Supreme Commander 2, while not as gargantuan as its predecessor, means that your limited time is best spent on planning overarching strategies rather than focusing on unit micromanagement like in many other real-time strategy games. It’s suicide to give a big mob of mixed units a general attack-move order in StarCraft, but it’s standard procedure in SupCom. Most of your time will be spent pondering larger issues like claiming new mass deposits and managing your research and production to counter your enemy. For the most part, SupCom 2 plays a lot like a zoomed-out version of a traditional RTS game. The gameplay lost by ditching unit micromanaging is made up for by the capability to execute grand strategies using multiple battlefronts and giant robots. There’s little to find fault with in the basic gameplay; it is very competent.

The problem is that “competent” is the best word to describe Supreme Commander 2. Where the original imaginatively invited players to approach economy in an entirely new way, the sequel falls back on genre norms. Rather than the slow resource drain of a working factory or engineer, SupCom 2 makes you pay for everything up front when you order its construction. This destroys the ever-expanding model of the first game, where the rate of your economic expansion is often more important than its moment-to-moment output. It’s still possible in theory to boom a sprawling economy past an opponent via buildings that convert energy to mass, but you’ll likely be pounded to oblivion long before you can make that strategy work

I’m disappointed by the sequel’s shift in vision on the big things, but other aspects of the game received much-needed improvements. Rather than having a full suite of unit types in each tier, your existing forces improve as you research better technology. This means that there is a lot less minutiae to track as a match progresses. Research has been similarly changed, moved from upgrading individual buildings to a global tree where you spend points garnered over time. While there are some boring but effective upgrades like “15% increased damage,” much of the available tech results in dramatic effects like adding shields to all your air units or unlocking impressive experimental units. The experimentals themselves are much more useful than in the original, with more available to each faction and a greater variety of roles on the battlefield.

It’s too bad that Supreme Commander 2 betrays so much of what made the original unique, as the iterative design and fine-tuning improvements across the smaller facets of the game are outstanding. Except for that whole “Square Enix is going to help us make a good story this time!” thing – the plot is lame as ever

You can have a good time with Supreme Commander 2. It’s just not all that different than the enjoyment to be found in any other solid RTS of the last decade. I would love to see someone mod SupCom 2’s units and research into the original’s overall structure.

Dial back some of the first game’s more aggressively unusual designs to make a large-scale RTS that more people can understand
Explosions are pretty enough, but you’ll spend a majority of your time zoomed out to the point that the war is being fought by icons
The lasers on the tanks go pew pew pew
The fantastic possibilities for automating your units and factories are ingenious, but I have to wait for the tooltip to make sure I’m building a laser turret instead of a mass extractor
This sequel finds itself in a no-man’s-land between the ambitious original and traditional RTS. Sending hundreds of robots to their doom is still amusing, though

Products In This Article

Supreme Commander 2cover

Supreme Commander 2

Xbox 360, PC
Release Date: