reader discussion
Rants 'N Raves: NCAA Football 11
Not everyone has the time to read or write a full review of every game that hits the market. Rants 'n Raves is your chance to read a quick breakdown of a game's strengths and weaknesses, as well as provide your own analysis. The concept is simple: put your pros and cons in a bullet point format, and make your critique of each bullet point as concise as you can. This week, we take a look at NCAA Football 11.
RAVES
- The new locomotion system reinvigorates the running game, making skilled backs feel like legit threats every time they touch the ball
- Removing the sprint button helps differentiate between skill players
- Real Assignment AI fixes the blocking mechanics in a way that makes formerly useless plays like draws and counters legit options for the first time
- New receiving animations around the boundaries demonstrate real awareness of the sidelines
- Quarterbacks throw out of sacks more often
- Refined recruiting gives you more feedback on how your pitches are affecting the player
- Fixed tackling stats during seasons so your players actually have a shot at leading the NCAA
- Dynasty Wire web/console toolset is a great way for players to chronicle their Online Dynasties
- Small presentation touches like stadium-specific intros and ESPN packaging help capture the college experience better than in years past
- Improved lighting and depth of field effects greatly improve the graphics
RANTS
- Linebackers still pick off too many mid-range passes over the middle
- Locomotion can feel overpowered with certain backs; no one can come to a stop right out of a dead sprint or run sideways at near full speed
- The AI runs the option ineffectively
- Clipping animations are still a problem in the receiver-defensive back interactions
- While generally improved, downfield blockers sometimes miss obvious targets and backs have a tough time picking up the blitz
- Commentary from Kirk Herbstreit and Brad Nessler is starting to sound stale
- Still bad play-calling in Road To Glory. These coaches are addicted to screens
- The stupid NCAA won't adopt a playoff postseason, but there's no reason why we can't have the option in the game!
What are your rants and raves? Share them in the comments below!

Get the Game Informer Print Edition!
Explore your favorite games in premium print format, delivered to your door.
- 10 issues per year
- Only $4.80 per issue
- Full digital magazine archive access
- Since 1991