Update: Overwatch Contenders Team Issues Statement Regarding Dropped Player Ellie

by Imran Khan on Jan 05, 2019 at 11:16 AM

Update 1/5: The Overwatch Contenders team Ellie had been signed to, Second Wind, has released a statement on Twitter regarding the situation. 

"When we originally onboarded Ellie, we had just recently lost players for various reasons and we desperately needed to find a substitute," the statement begins. At the time, Second Wind had relied on the Overwatch leaderboards to field its players, and Ellie had achieved rank 4 on the North American servers. Other members of Second Wind had also played with Ellie and, with the roster deadline looming, the team approached Ellie, who seemed fairly straightforward with them. Out of respect for Ellie's privacy, the team did not fully verify their identity, which is not a requirement to compete in the Contenders league. "We underestimated how important it would be to set an example as the first team to take on a female player for Contenders," the team said.

After signing Ellie, Second Wind then began working with Blizzard to verify their identity, but also began prepping Ellie for interviews and public appearances, including a chance to play with the team in a public setting. "This unfortunately fell through due to Ellie opting out for 'personal reasons' we did not want to press them for," Second Wind said. As Ellie began receiving personal and doxxing threats, the team asked Blizzard to not publish Ellie's name on the official Contenders website, which could have invited more threats and scrutiny. "As a team, we admit we handled this poorly," the team said. "More could have been done to support our players, but we had found ourselves unprepared for the attention Ellie got upon their onboarding; we had full faith in them. Due to our desperation to fill a roster, we unfortunately overlooked crucial information that should have been paid more attention to."

Eventually, Ellie removed herself from the team, according to Second Wind. Yesterday, Blizzard notified Second Wind that Ellie had not been deceiving the team, and that the high-ranked account had been "used for purposes we do not support," referencing the "social experiment" Punisher was allegedly conducting with the account. "We apologize to the community as a whole for not handling this situation better when we should have, and we will aim to do better."

Update 1/4: Streamers such as Punisher, who supposedly streamed with Ellie, are now stating that the entire thing was a social experiment created by them. Based on their admissions on-stream, Punisher asked a 17-year-old girl to pose as him while he played for an experiment that he has yet to explain. We have reached out to Punisher, who has not replied as of time of writing.

Reports on Twitter have suggested that Blizzard is now holding meetings with the team Second Wind. We have reached out to Blizzard as well.

The original story is as follows:

There's a lot of drama in professional Overwatch, but harassment and potential threats of doxxing causing one player to have to step down from her team is not the drama anyone expected. Ellie, a player for Overwatch's minor league, Overwatch Contenders, has quit the team Second Wind after weeks of harassment accusing her of not being who she says she is.

Ellie signed onto Second Wind slightly before Christmas on December 21, a move which otherwise would have made very few waves in the Overwatch community. The announcement tweet from Second Wind simply congratulates her by including her Twitter handle and leaves it at that. A few days later, Ellie tweets some screenshots from her own account that had presumably been passed to her showing a coordinated effort in a Discord room to doxx her, which is finding personal information like addresses, phone numbers, real names, etc. about someone.

"It’s doxxing time," the chat message says in the screenshot. "Not for malicious intent, just to figure s--- out." It was from a high-ranked, though banned, player named Haunt.

Whereas other players had all used their legal name when participating on Second Wind, Ellie did not. According to Overwatch Contenders rules, as well as Second Wind's own rules, using your legal name isn't required, and many players in esports in general go by screen names alone. However, this seemed to arouse suspicion in the community, some of whom began crafting a conspiracy theory that Ellie was using a fake name and, if she were using a fake name, what else could she be lying about? They reasoned that this Overwatch player they had never heard of who had suddenly climbed to the top of the ranking charts was likely a professional player pretending to be a woman.

The claim was, of course, entirely baseless. At no point was there any corroborating evidence to support this notion beyond her reluctance to supply her full name. This appeared to only strengthen the fervor around "outing" her, however.

To prove her existence, Ellie streamed Overwatch with some other professional players, including a player named Punisher who her decriers were accusing her of being. If it convinced anyone, they were not quick to show it. Overwatch League player and Atlanta Reigns member Daniel "Dafran" Francesca pushed a theory during a stream that, despite Ellie talking on stream, she was merely providing fake commentary while "someone else is playing on his account."

Late last night, Second Wind announced that she would be stepping down "due to unforeseen reactions." Ellie herself simply posted a single-word "sorry" on her Twitter account and has not engaged since.

Second Wind owner Justin Hughes posted his own thoughts on Twitter, suggesting that Ellie was being pulled in multiple directions and threats were part of the reason she had to step down. "When we brought her onto the team, people acted like we had brought on a symbol of empowerment," Hughes tweeted. "I get that people meant well, but on one side, we had people questioning her legitimacy, issuing threats, etc. while on the other hand, we had people acting like they had found their Messiah. Between needing a player to live up to huge expectations and having to question their own safety, it seems that the OW community isn’t ready to just view a player as just a player. We wanted a player, but it seemed like the public wanted something else. Sorry about my pronoun usage. However, the message remains the same."


Speculation about the mysterious lives of players will happen as long as society maintains and encourages parasocial relationships with people they've never met, but I genuinely do not believe any of this would happen to this extent if Ellie's name was Steve and she was a man. I don't think it's even arguable that it would. Even if she wasn't who she says – a claim for which there is zero evidence but let's engage the hypothetical – what right does anyone else really have to know? The claims of esports being a meritocracy where anyone can be good enough to be a part of the club as long as they can play have long been suspect, but this saga essentially proves them wrong. It is no longer about whether you can play, it's about whether you can prove yourself worthy of the onus we put upon you.