Switch Lights

The lights are on

What's Happening

Ubisoft Files Complaint Against Author That Sued Over Assassin's Creed

 

While author John Beiswenger, who claimed Ubisoft had stolen elements of his novel Link when it created the Assassin's Creed series, had recently ended his lawsuit against the company, the story might not be over.

According to Gamasutra, Ubisoft has filed a complaint against Beiswenger and wants a ruling that his claims of copyright infringement were "entirely meritless."

If you're wondering why Ubisoft is still pursuing legal action on a lawsuit that has been withdrawn, there is a good reason. Beiswenger's lawsuit was ended "without prejudice" -- which means that he was free to make claims of copyright infringement against Ubisoft anytime in the future.

In a statement, an Ubisoft representative said, "The plaintiff in the case alleging copyright infringement by Ubisoft has dropped his claim, without settlement. Ubisoft believes this suit was frivolous and without merit, and is seeking a ruling to prevent future related claims. We are proud of our creative teams and will continue to vigorously defend the intellectual property they develop."

If Ubisoft is successful in getting a ruling that the original suit was meritless, the door will be closed to further legal action on Beiswenger's part.

This whole thing is getting more complicated than the plot to the Assassin's Creed series itself -- or the plot to Beiswenger's Link, depending on who you believe.

Email the author , or follow on , and .

Comments
  • Link should get more money
  • I'm going with the Assassin's creed series being more complicated
  • This is getting messy, hate that all these law suits are going on nowadays...
  • In other news Ubisoft pokes bear...bear eat Ubisoft...
  • god, this whole thing is ridiculous.
  • I think Miyamoto should sue Beiswenger for naming his book after Zelda's savior.
  • Frivolous suit-bringers beware... Take a jab at the slumbering beast, you'd best be ready to slay it.
  • This should be interesting

  • http://www.amazon.com/Link-Beiswenger-John-L/dp/0741413485

    "The author lets the reader be present right alongside the scientists as they uncover some of the very secrets of Creation, and while test subjects are taken back in time to recall ancestral memories, a process key to proving the existence of the human soul."

    I can see now the basis where this lawsuit is coming from...I might check out the book.

    Edit: Did not see the original GI article relating to this issue....yeah they already pointed out what I just posted.
  • I feel like we'll find out Beiswenger's novel was written, like, a year after Assassin's Creed came out.

    EDIT: Never mind, I found out the book was published in 2003.
  • Genetic memory time travel was first explored to my knowledge in Altered States, and was posited before that by many philosophers, scientists, and new age flakes.

    This guy deserves to have his arse smacked for the trouble he caused.

  • Ubisoft...I believe Ubisoft.
  • Meh... After the BethesdaSoft/Mojang debacle, this is nothing. Just let them have their Animus, Mister Beiswenger.
  • Go Ubisoft!!!!! Bury this talentless loser writer!!!!
  • Nothing is true, everything is permitted.
  • It's possible that Ubisoft thought up the premise of the AC series entirely on their own without any outside inspiration...

    ...just as it's possible that someone at Ubisoft read this guy's books and said, "Hey, this would make for a pretty cool game."

    God only knows :\

  • i wonder how many of the people b****ing about this have read the book in question... doesn't really seem fair to blast ubisoft or beiswenger only knowing assassin's creed
  • The way I see it, if the author pressed charges within the first year the first game was out there would be some merit to his cause. But the Assassin's Creed franchise has become so huge that it's become its own separate entity. I'm sorry Beiswenger but your suit is too little, too late.
  • This is the song that never ends.

    I wonder how easy it is to just come up with an idea and have it resemble someone else's so much that you get sued?  After all, there is nothing new under the sun, or so they say.

  • well, I'm conflicted. a part of me absolutely loves the AC franchise and wants it to continue, another thinks this man is completely right in thinking they violated his copyright and deserves a cut of the AC pie.
1 2 3 Next