It's happening again. Our longest Replay episode ever was of Mario Party 3, and fans of the show seemed to love watching our agony. My guests never wanted to do another Mario Party episode, but Joe Juba had to go to the Overblood Facebook group and make a bet with them. He lost, and their (and your) reward is yet another episode of Mario Party.

For this go-round, I selected the first entry in the long-running series for Joe, Reiner, Matt, and myself to play. If you're familiar with this particular title, you'll understand completely why the middle of my right palm is sore as I type this. You can see things get predictably ugly below.

(Note: this is not the beginning of Replay season 2. Reiner wanted this to be a "bonus episode" between the two seasons)

Want more Replay? Check out every episode over at our hub page.