Please support Game Informer. Print magazine subscriptions are less than $2 per issue

X
Review

Sam and Max: Season One Review

Telltale Proves That Re-runs Aren't Always Fun
by Matthew Kato on Sep 22, 2009 at 02:01 PM
Reviewed on Wii
Publisher The Adventure Company
Developer Telltale Games
Release
Rating Teen

Sam & Max enjoys a cult following for the pair's sense of humor, and that's a good thing for an adventure game, since elements like humor or storyline add some weight to the physically mundane tasks of pointing and clicking. When the laughter dies and some of the jokes fall flat, however, Sam & Max teeters as its gameplay is unable to support much interest for some stretches.

The game doesn't veer much from the standard point-and-click adventure genre formula of navigating static environments collecting useful items and searching for clues. This means you spend lots of time running around trying to interact with whatever you can to solve puzzles. The problems I have with this title's puzzles start with the trial-and-error variety and continue with some puzzles that you wouldn't know the answer to until you exhaust all your options. In other words, at times you're trying to solve a puzzle you don't necessarily know is a puzzle or whose start point is a little outside the boundaries of logic.

Thankfully, at other times the game lets the player simply enjoy or create their own fun outside of puzzle solving, such as the sheer amount of dialogue that has been recorded for the characters for you to enjoy. You can even make up your own lyrics for a song on a show called ''Embarrassing Idol.''

Some memories are cherished because they are a part of your past. That doesn't always mean they are good ones, however. This game is enjoyable in limited contexts – whether you're a Sam & Max fan or more just after an old fashioned adventure game with occasional good laughs. Unfortunately, that's too many caveats to make Sam & Max an adventure truly worth recommending.

7
Concept
This game encapsulates the six new Sam & Max episodes originally released via GameTap on the PC
Graphics
A perfect, naturally cartoony fit for the Wii
Sound
I was amazed at the sheer number of lines recorded for the main characters, with some good jokes tucked away throughout the game
Playability
A dash mechanic makes getting around this adventure title thankfully easy
Entertainment
There are some laughs to be had here, but they can be as scarce as the gameplay at times
Replay
Moderately Low

Products In This Article

Sam and Max: Season Onecover

Sam and Max: Season One

Platform:
Wii
Release Date: