The lights are on
What new ideas the game brings to the table and how well old ideas are presented.
How good a game looks, taking into account any flaws such as bad collision or pop-up.
Does the game’s music and sound effects get you involved or do they make you resolve to always play with the volume down?
Basically, the controller to human interface. The less you think about the hunk of plastic in your hands, the better the playability.
Flat out, just how fun the game is to play. The most important factor in rating a game.
When an Activision game is successful, a sequel is likely to follow
in the next year. Activision transformed Call of Duty into a
multimillion selling annual event, but exploited the Guitar Hero and
Tony Hawk series until they reached bargain bin status. Skylanders
appears to be the publisher’s next perennial cash cow.
store shelves just a year after the release of Skylanders: Spyro’s
Adventure, Skylanders Giants follows its predecessor’s blueprint. As
such, the Skylands are once again filled with block-moving puzzles,
collectible hats, pushable turtles, breakable crates filled with gems,
an annoying green creature that lives inside of locks, doors requiring
multiple keys, character tokens that unlock videos of purchasable
figurines, element-specific secret zones, and boss fights against shadow
versions of many of the popular Skylanders characters. Since Spyro’s
Adventure covered the gamut of standard world types – be it fire, snow,
or haunted village – most of Giants’ level designs retread these themes.
It’s the same song and dance.
And that’s okay. If this were the
fourth or fifth entry in the series, its charm may have worn off, but I
had a blast playing this game even if it is painfully familiar most of
The biggest difference between the two entries is the
addition of new Giant characters. These lumbering titans stand in at
roughly twice the height of standard Skylanders, and can be summoned to
lift boulders, smash through weak floorboards, run through walls, and
pull gigantic chains. On the battlefield, they punch harder and move a
little slower, but fit right in with the other Skylanders’ assortment of
short-and long-range attack strategies.
When it comes to world
exploration, the Giants are a little too slow, and are tight squeezes on
narrow paths. As I looked for secrets, I would switch these sloths out
for the faster dragon characters, but used them as much as I could in
large-scale conflicts or against approaching swarms. The Giants are
particularly useful in the new Arena challenges, which pit one Skylander
against numerous waves of foes.
Think of the Giants as a ninth
class, joining the likes of Earth, Fire, and Undead. Although each Giant
is aligned to one of those specific traits, only the fact that they are
Giants matters in determining which areas they can enter. You won’t
need a Water Giant or a Tech Giant at any specific point; one Giant
(like Tree Rex, who is packaged with the game) is enough to uncover all
of the hidden areas.
All 32 previously released Skylanders
figurines work with this sequel, and can attain five additional levels
to reach the new cap of 15. These levels pass slowly, allowing players
to keep their favorite characters in play for a majority of the time.
New difficulty settings up the challenge for seasoned players, but even
Hard is a little easy. You unlock the most difficult setting, Nightmare,
after completing the game.
Two unexpected joys came from Giants.
One: The story. I didn’t much care for the cinematics in Spyro’s
Adventure, but laughed frequently at the nicely penned humor in Giants.
Most of the jokes are tied to Lord Kaos, his bid for power, and his
loveable butler Glumshanks. My second unexpected joy was a new
collectible card game. In most of the levels, you obtain new cards by
purchasing them from vendors or beating rival card players in matches. I
always like it when games put a collectible item like these cards to
Although Skylanders characters are rarely asked to leave
their feet, these games remind me of the great Insomniac Games and
Naughty Dog platformers from the PlayStation 1 and 2 eras. I wouldn’t
necessarily categorize them as collect-a-thons, but the hunt for hidden
loot is one of this series’ strongest elements, not to mention the
thrill of racing through levels to hit a par time. Although Skylanders’
gameplay more closely matches the hack n’ slash genre, the spirit of the
long-lost platformer is alive and well here.
Pending a retail
disaster this year, I suspect another Skylanders sequel is already in
development and slated for release next holiday. Giants makes a good
case for the fun and collectibility of this series, but also raises the
warning flag for franchise fatigue.
Email the author Andrew Reiner, or follow on Twitter, Facebook, and Game Informer.