The lights are on
Power Member - Level 10
This article was originally published on zeldadungeon.net under the name Keaton, because that is my first name.
I'm open to fair criticism of games that I enjoy. I try to
keep an open mind because I realize people have wildly different views of games
and what makes them fun to play. I don't believe any game is perfect, and that
a healthy dose of criticism is sometimes needed to help keep a game in
perspective. The problem is that too many people these days try to tear popular
games apart with often baseless criticisms. One such criticism is a real
pet-peeve of mine: I can't stand when people try to write a classic game off by
claiming players only enjoy it because they're nostalgic for it.
First of all, it's one of the most general statements that
can be made in dissent of a game. Anyone who makes said statement does not have
to cite specific flaws in the game design, mention aspects they didn't find
enjoyable, or provide other reasons for why the game isn't as great as everyone
says. While there are those who make an honest effort to go more in-depth with
such a criticism, most say something along these lines: "This game might be fun
for a little nostalgia, but it's actually terrible." Not surprisingly, a lot of
these attacks seem to be aimed at Nintendo. I can't count how many times I've
read about how terrible Mario games are, and that nostalgic players are all
that keeps the series going. One major flaw with this criticism is how easy it
is to debunk. Ocarina of Time is my go-to game for doing just that.
I recently had the misfortune of witnessing Ocarina of Time
fall victim to this very criticism. It's a little hard for me to believe,
because my experience with Ocarina of Time has shown quite the opposite. I
never played Ocarina of Time until only a few years ago, so when I did finally
play it, there was nothing I could be nostalgic about. Instead, I discovered a
new experience that immediately earned a spot among my favorite games of all
time. Again, this wasn't a childhood game I returned to, it was only the second
Zelda game I ever played, right after A Link to the Past. You can't simply
chalk my enjoyment of Ocarina of Time up to nostalgia, because there was no way
for me to be nostalgic about it in the first place.
As confounding as it is for someone to maintain this stance
on Ocarina of Time even when I'm right there telling my story, I must admit
that there may be some truth in what they are saying. Yes, all this enjoyment
from nostalgia babble isn't total hogwash. While I would love to tell this
person, "You've never played Ocarina of Time, because anyone who has actually
played it would never say that," I may be completely wrong. I know it's hard
for us to imagine, but maybe this person genuinely did not enjoy Ocarina of
Time. It would be unfair of me to make the assumption that this person never
played the game.
Personally, there are a few games I still play now and then
for the sake of nostalgia. I recognize the flaws of these games, and sometimes
even ask myself why I ever loved them so much in the first place. Sometimes
they're older games from a series that I return to just to marvel at how far
the series has come. But if you ask me, Ocarina of Time is an immortal classic.
My point is, I know what kinds of games that I enjoy for the nostalgia, and
which I don't. Just because someone else wasn't able to enjoy a game doesn't
mean they should try to ruin it for everyone else by asserting that we're
blinded by nostalgia. It's even worse when someone makes this claim about a
game they've never played. I implore you; if there is a classic game you don't
find to be your cup of tea, please try to consider that other players may have
honestly enjoyed it.
So, how do you think nostalgia affects our
experiences with video games? Are we too often looking at things through
rose-colored glasses, or do plenty of older games stand the test of time? And
most importantly, do you think enjoyment only for nostalgia is a fair criticism
against games? The comments section is there for a reason!