GameInformer

since the hole game is pretty much based around this idea to a degree anyway, i thought id ask everyone. For me at the moment anyway it was killing a store clerk in armadillo for making an anti semtic comment.

When going for the Dastardly achievement I waited until I came across one of the fake women in distress that has a gang jump you when you ride up to help her, then I killed the gang and hogtied her.

I've been waiting to find one of the fakers for that achievement as well, but every time I end up finding one, I stop too close and get dismounted... end up having to shoot her -_-,

So far I really haven't done anything bad in single player at all, except for accidentally killing the old man with some land very early in the game... I had just finished dialog with him, and a rabbit ran by that I felt compelled to shoot... so I did... and he didn't like that I guess so he started shooting me... and then he was dead :( Woops

lol.... i killed him on my maverick playthrough. o and on my new playthrough i killed that old guy on. Flower For A Lady quest.

wow alot of NOTHING on this group...

I think the myriad E3 posts are getting all the heat. Next week stuff will go back to "normal" I imagine.

lol i hope so... i come on here once or twice a day to see if theres any useful tips for online and so far nothing in like 5 days...

Yeah, well in-so-far as I am concerned, I've been AFX for just over a week now, so not a lot to add for RDR or anything else. I'll be back in the saddle Monday though.

I just shot a bunch of prostitutes. Oh and I blew up Theives Landing with dynamite. Good times, good times.

not really justifiable but still fun to do.

I really stayed true to playing the good guy through my entire playthrough (besides my accidental murder of the old man with the land deed), with one exception later on.

So I'm like 80% through the game... and STILL, no one has ever challenged me to a duel inside of Armadillo. I've nearly completely the game, and have yet to take advantage of my reserve bonus (The deadly assassin outfit)... and I'm starting to get a little pissed. So pissed I could push someone! So I did.

I went on a pushing rampage. Every last person in Armadillo got shoved to the ground. After realizing this isn't a crime unless you do it to a lawman, this became my favorite pastime. Walking through town? Shove a guy off a horse. Shove someone from behind and watch them slide on their face. Maybe even kick em a few times - it ain't a crime!

Whether this rampage was a factor or not, I did get my duel the next time I visited.

I've shot peoples horses out from under them, then ran them over before killing them, but then I usually feel sorry for the horses. :(  

But that's not very justifiable, just funny-looking.

true... i try to shoot people in the feet off there horses then i try to shoot the horses in there feet so i killed less horses in the game but since that only worked 10 percent of the time it still showed that i had killed over 1900 domesiticated horses...

THe most justifiable wrong thing I have ever done is get my bounty up to $12000 by going on a shooting rampage because of the anger I felt when John Marston died.

I used the Deadly Assassin's outfit more than most of my friends who had it; if you're worried it's under used, try playing with the expert aiming controls. When you don't get any aim-assisst, you'll be using a lot more Dead Eye.

I consider all wrongs done in the name of achievements to be rightful, particularly since I completed most such achievements after completing the story (which for spoilery reasons doesn't feel like a break in character).