I give the game a 10 just like the upcoming movie.  Why, because my 9 year old little boy loves this game and among all the games he has played on the 360 he loves this one the most and came to me in my sleep, crying that he loves the game and wishes it were real.  My boy is intelligent, loving and honest and many other wonderful things. So GI take your 4.5, put it where the sun don't shine, and stop downplaying games you aren't as good at, as a 9 year old.  The graphics are unbelievable, the game play cool as hell, the sounds and music, is immersive, and Yes my family members including me are Tronnies.