The lights are on
It's so bad. Just a complete let down with terrible controls and dodgy graphic. The Pirates of the Caribbean game on the original Xbox is exponentially better than this, but the main thing I dislike about this game is the wasted opportunities. Risen 2 sets itself up through a great cutscene and then watches as that potentially awesome experience sails over the horizon.
And you cannot sail a pirate ship....ever...
It gets 1 point for the dialogue.