The lights are on
What new ideas the game brings to the table and how well old ideas are presented.
How good a game looks, taking into account any flaws such as bad collision or pop-up.
Does the game’s music and sound effects get you involved or do they make you resolve to always play with the volume down?
Basically, the controller to human interface. The less you think about the hunk of plastic in your hands, the better the playability.
Flat out, just how fun the game is to play. The most important factor in rating a game.
With Ion Storm dead and celebrated creators Warren Spector and Harvey Smith each in new stages of their careers, developer Eidos Montreal faces the difficult task of bringing back one of gaming’s most celebrated series. Eidos sticks to Ion’s original vision, offering a game that supports deep stealth, combat, exploration, and RPG-style upgrade and conversation systems. Throughout most of this adventure, the player is empowered with an authoritative role over the gameplay flow. Depending on how a scenario is approached, individualized tactics can produce varied results that impact the story, obtainable loot, and shape of the world. An entire courtyard of civilians could end up dead, or the only casualty could be a computer’s security system getting hacked. Unfortunately, not all of these mechanics work as well as others, and your enjoyment is tied to how heavily you lean on the more polished portions.In addition to the vast amounts of player choice, Human Revolution weaves an amazing story filled with heady techno-babble. In the year 2027 (25 years before the events in the first game in the series), society is struggling with the ethics of augmenting the human body with mechanical implants. The debate is at a tipping point, and what happens next won’t be determined by the people but rather the biotechnology companies and the corrupt governments that back them. Players take the role of Adam Jensen, an ex-SWAT officer turned security specialist for biotech company Sarif Industries, who finds himself intertwined with the conspiracies. After a rival biotech company injures him in an attack, he unwillingly receives augmentations, putting him in a unique position to understand the costs and benefits of the technology.
For most of my first of two complete playthroughs of Human Revolution I relied on stealth tactics to achieve my goals. Sneaking through rival office spaces and biotechnology labs is an exhilarating experience. A fantastic cover mechanic and unpredictable enemy behavior enhance this approach, but it requires patience. I often found myself hiding behind a crate to learn an enemy’s routine before engaging. Moving like a ghost gets the blood pumping, especially in heavily fortified areas loaded with patrols, turrets, and cameras. The reward isn’t just the satisfaction of getting through a zone undetected. Along the way, you can loot offices, hack computers, and uncover additional weapons, items, and story content. I loved how often I found myself debating if I should take a risk for a potential reward. Almost every environment dangles tasty carrots in front of the player; some are obtainable from the outset, others require backtracking once the player reaches higher ranks for hacking or strength. I still have several secret locations I want to return to scribbled in my notepad.
Exploring the cities is one of this game’s most rewarding experiences. I know this doesn’t sound like an enthralling activity, but the soaring architecture in each city produces multi-tiered exploration across rooftops, into the backrooms of stores, through seedy alleys and into heavily populated living quarters. The Blade Runner-esque environments are packed with high-tech architecture and a sense of despair hangs over the proceedings. Every character in the game, whether it’s a bum digging through a trashcan or a security guard positioned on a helipad, can be talked to. They may give a canned response, or they may seek help and offer up a secondary mission to take on. Most of these characters have interesting stories to tell, and many of the secrets that are found provide extensive backstory for the world and its locals.Jensen’s personality mirrors that of The Matrix’s Neo. This guy radiates boredom, but despite his monotone emotions, he’s a skilled conversationalist capable of negotiating with terrorists and bending people to his will. Just like Mass Effect, the player controls the tone of these conversations. After hearing a pitch from his boss, Jensen can respond with an intrigued, grudging, or callous thought. A hostage situation brings up conversation threads for humbled, reasoned, and empathetic approaches. These choices are not the only factors at play; characters often reveal their true intentions through body language. The conversation system is brilliantly devised, and all of the writing within it is top notch. Even ridiculous character names like “Anonymous X” are met with the appropriate levels of dry sarcasm from Jensen.
Although Jensen is outfitted in the latest and greatest that biotechnology has to offer, his arms run on cheap batteries – worse than the generic varieties packaged with TVs. Whenever Jensen performs a stealth takedown, he drains this battery. If he only has one active cell, which is usually the case, he can’t perform another takedown until the battery charges. That’s right: A character with state of the art metal arms can’t choke or punch an enemy without cell energy. He just has to stand behind them and wait for 30 to 40 seconds (upgrades can reduce the time). If the enemy turns, Jensen can enter his inventory to consume an energy bar – you read that correctly, he stops for a snack – to restore energy instantly. The ridiculousness of this concept is blatant. In the future, if your TV remote’s batteries die, try plugging carbohydrates into it.
Having multiple charged cells further breaks the stealth experience. Since a stealth takedown transitions to an animation sequence that freezes the action, Jensen can bounce from one enemy to the next with little risk. A guard, standing no more than two feet away from a friend Jensen is brutally stabbing, won’t do anything during the animation. He just stands there until the animation concludes. By then, it’s too late – I’ve already initiated a stealth takedown on him. If you can picture dominoes getting stabbed and falling in a bloody mess, you have an idea of how Human Revolution’s battery cells can break the experience.Computer hacking also suffers from balance issues. Once Jensen upgrades his hacking stealth to level three (which can be achieved within a matter of hours) he decreases the chance of detection by 45 percent and the thrill of hacking is lost until you come across the level five security rating terminals toward the end of the game. Hacking is a huge portion of this game, used to break into all locked doors, safes, and computers. Do yourself a favor and base your hacking upgrades on the progressive increases in difficulty. Bypassing security systems can be a lot of fun when it's balanced just right.
Upgrading Jensen’s augmentations opens up new gameplay options and, as the hacking illustrates, overly effective advantages. Some of the augmentations add new skills (like the ability to see through walls), while others (like the ability to lift heavy objects) add to Jensen’s exploration opportunities. Choose your augmentations wisely, as the sheer number of options can shape Jensen in completely different ways and potentially keep large sections of the game blocked off. I finished every side mission I came across and spent hours exploring, and still had 30 upgrades left to activate at the game’s conclusion. Sadly, no new game plus option is offered.When I was feeling up for a challenge, I would engage in firefights. The guns are responsive and work well with the smartly designed cover system, but when enemies are alerted their intelligence is often stripped away. On rare occasions they’ll rush Jensen’s location (which often is countered with a cheap stealth kill). Most of the time, they’ll hunker into one cover location and bob up and down to take shots. They often throw themselves directly into harm’s way, and their lack of aggressiveness means Jensen can often sit in one place to pick them all off. On the plus side, Jensen can’t take too many hits. A few shots to the chest and he’ll be down and out. Bullets are also hard to come by. While the gunplay is exploitable to a degree, it does strike a nice balance with Jensen’s limited health and ammo to create intense battles.Combat is most disappointing in the boss battles – horribly repetitious arena fights against super-powered foes that can usually drop Jensen before he even knows what hit him. My approach to these difficult conflicts was to get off to a good start, save my game, then repeat this process until they were defeated. In the last boss battle, I hid in a closet shelf until the boss’ weakness was revealed – not exactly the epic showdown I was expecting.
I know I take issue with many aspects of this game, but these flaws don’t hold Human Revolution back from being an entertaining adventure through a riveting story and world. It rewards those who fight through it with a fantastic plot payoff and a great sense of character progression. The problematic gunplay AI and annoying stealth takedown mechanics keep the game from greatness, but if played a certain way, Human Revolution captures the spirit of its predecessors and can be a blast. Even if it’s not a masterpiece, this entry lays the groundwork for a promising future for the series.
Email the author Andrew Reiner, or follow on Twitter, Facebook, and Game Informer.