I think the GI review of this game was a little harsh. While Wii is certainly the worst platform to play this game on, it is still very fun. Graphics are the biggest downgrade. Basically, it looks like you are playing a PS2 game. While the control scheme takes a couple of hours to get used to, it works very well once you get the hang of it. I recommend putting the control scheme on the "n00b" setting, at least until you figure things out. The campaign is just as epic, and the multiplayer is almost as good as the original (only 10 players max and no voice chat). Having played both the 360 and Wii versions extensively, I think my opinion carries some weight.