Tim Schafer Raises His Goblet Of Rock - Brutal Legend - PlayStation 3 - www.GameInformer.com
Switch Lights

The lights are on

Brutal Legend

Tim Schafer Raises His Goblet Of Rock

What a long, strange ride it’s been for heavy metal. A movement that started as a critically reviled cacophony of distorted amps, screeching vocals, and gaudy guitar solos has proven exceptionally resilient, with its biggest bands selling out stadiums across the world over three decades. Metal faced many near-death moments that would have killed lesser genres – men in make-up, spandex, and Fred Durst – but it ultimately persevered, crossing over into new media with triumphant success stories like Metalocalypse and Guitar Hero. Famed game developer Tim Schafer grew up during metal’s rise to popularity, and Brütal Legend serves as his ode to the heavy, brooding music of his adolescence. This is a fantastical metal opus stitched together from album covers, rock videos, band merch, and live concerts.

Brütal Legend follows the exploits of Eddie Riggs, a roadie voiced by Jack Black who gets transported to an alternate dimension steeped in metal lore after he spills blood on his belt buckle during a stage mishap. The evil Lord Doviculus and his demons have enslaved humanity, and Riggs joins dreamy resistance frontman Lars Halford’s cause to return mankind to righteousness. This tour won’t be easy, however, as Riggs encounters tragedy, lost love, and his own shady past as he struggles to harness the power of metal and dethrone Doviculus. Tim Schafer’s signature sense of humor is pervasive throughout, with subtle metal references and laugh-out-loud one-liners strewn across the narrative.

Eddie proves no slouch in the combat arena, bludgeoning enemies with his axe, shredding his guitar for ranged lightning attacks, and turning demons into road kill with his steel chariot, The Deuce. Double Fine’s combat controls aren’t difficult to master, but the action is kept fresh with combos, double team attacks that pair Eddie with his comrades, and special powers Eddie calls to his aid via guitar riffs. These creative and highly useful attacks range from melting the faces of the enemies around him to calling in a flaming zeppelin that crashes to the ground, eliminating or severely damaging everyone in its path. Metal indeed.

Riggs unlocks these powers by scavenging the land for Tab Slabs, large rock structures that teach the destructive guitar solos. Finding them isn’t easy given the open world’s breadth, but fantastic art direction guarantees the drive is filled with awe-inspiring monuments to metal. From the screeching wall of amps to the mountains of skulls, the world of Brütal Legend is living, breathing album cover, and one of the most imaginative game worlds I have visited. Collectibles and side missions with cameo performances from Kyle Gass and Brian Posehn litter the explorable metalscape.

To win the land back from his enemies, Eddie must engage in “Stage Battles,” the centerpiece to the Brütal Legend combat and multiplayer experience. To win these action/real-time strategy hybrid battles, you must gain control of “fan geysers” by building merch booths on top of them to harness the fan spirits. With the fans on his side, Eddie can call a great array of varied unit types to arms, or turn the tide of battle by joining the fray himself. RTS battles rely on split second decisions, but Brütal Legend’s cumbersome command system stretches your patience to wit’s end. If your tactics aren’t sound from the first note there is rarely a course of recovery. The multiplayer gives you the chance to control the goth/emo and demonic factions you battle in the single-player game, but with the core mechanic so unreliable I can’t see this being a destination mode.

The unwieldy Stage Battles maim the battle system and multiplayer, but this gaffe doen’t take away from Brütal Legend’s charm. If you’re a fan of Tim Schafer’s humor and the type of person who decides between wearing a Metallica and Slayer tee-shirt when you wake up, this is a must-play.

Email the author , or follow on , , , and .

Second Opinion:


Brütal Legend is hilariously scripted, brilliantly imaginative, visually and aurally arresting, and frequently unpolished throughout its many varied approaches to gameplay. The game borrows endlessly from every genre you can think of: RPG story and upgrade systems, large-scale RTS battles, open world exploration, and everything in between. Many of those systems have flaws; simplification of each gameplay mechanic is so severe that it hurts the experience. In particular, the strategy sections can be frustrating to navigate until you learn some workarounds. The good news is that you might not notice, given how absorbed you’ll be in the amazing setting that Double Fine has crafted. From the huge list of licensed music to the environments stuffed full of rock metaphors, the game is one big homage to metal, couched in the irreverent humor you’d expect from Tim Schafer. It’s not perfect, but you owe it to yourself to explore one of the most clever and engaging fictional worlds in years.

User Reviews:

  • 9.00
    Initially, the game Brutal Legend may not be love at first sight. What with this game not being part of a blockbuster franchise and the fact that the creator Tim Schafer isn't very well-known outside of the Video game industry may block people from gaining much interest in this game. Please, do not...
    read more
  • 8.75
    As far as story line goes, Brütal Legend is amazing. I grew up in the 80s/90s listening to many of the bands featured on the soundtrack, but as the music became more Kabbage Boy, less Motorhead (and as I took off my blinders and broadened my musical horizons), I found myself dragging out those old...
    read more
  • 8.00
    Brutal Legend has incredible artwork – the environments are stunning in both their beauty and creativity, the characters were bizarre and fascinating, and the story was clever. I really enjoyed the opportunities to immerse myself in the world, but it always took a little bit of work to ignore the...
    read more
  • 8.50
    My usual Good vs. Bad review (MAY CONTAIN SPOILERS! You have been warned) So, I have been following and waiting for this game almost a year and must say, I have a lot of mixed emotions... This game is good, actually, it's great! But there are some things that kinda make it frustrating and avoidable...
    read more
  • 8.25
    Score: 8.25/10 Brutal Legend Xbox 360/PS3 Developer: Double Fine Publisher: EA Release Date: October 13, 2009 Pros: Hilarious voice work and dialogue, unique worlds, fitting soundtrack, relatively enjoyable multiplayer, loads of collectibles Cons: Targeting can be a pain, repetitive side missions, no...
    read more
  • 10.00
    Finally a game that gives metal heads praise. This game is beyind belief. When will you be able to see Rock Gods like Lemmy Killmeister, Lita Ford and OZZY FREAKING OSBOURNE in a game together. The stage battles are sweet. The creatures look like they were just ripped off a Heavy Metal album cover. The...
    read more