Switch Lights

The lights are on

What's Happening

I’m Not One Of Your Statistics…

I'm really trying to move past all this talk of gun violence and video game violence but it seems like every time I turn around I see something else on the subject. One of the most troubling statements I saw recently was from Brian Kolb, Assembly Republican Leader, New York Assembly (and for the record I am a Republican so I'm not being biased, just disappointed).

"When we desensitize with video games are we contributing to these young people that have issues differentiating between real and unreal violence..."

I've been a gamer a long time; longer than some of you have been alive. I've played all sorts of games, violent and not, for my whole life - from childhood to present. It's funny, because I've never really made a distinction between which ones were violent and which ones weren't. I just played them. They were (and still are) a big part of my life growing up.

My brother and I were home alone often, and not allowed to go outside (so the neighbors wouldn't call the cops for us being unattended). We would resort to playing video games to occupy our time. We played whatever we could get our hands on. I don't even remember where we got them from, I certainly never remember my parents (which were split up by the way) buying them, and Al Gore hadn't invented the Internet yet for us to download them. But we had them.

At a very young age, my brother and I were frequently dropped off at the local arcade for hours at a time with a little bit of money and we would stay there until around midnight. The arcade would close and we'd be stuck outside waiting for my mom to show up to retrieve us. This was like an every Friday and/or Saturday night event. I can remember spending all my money within the first 2 hours (or 20 minutes) and then spend the remainder of the night just hanging out, searching all the coin returns in the various machines for a token somebody missed.

Well, I don't want to sit here and bore you all with the specifics of my childhood, and I'm not going to detail all of the errors my parents made raising my brother and I. We didn't have it as rough as some, but I certainly wasn't born with a silver spoon in my mouth either. I think I turned out okay.

One of the things I've battled with my entire life though is the "statistics" of what I'm at risk of...a lot of it based solely on the behavior of my family, or friends, or like-minded people who are categorized because they engage in similar activities.

Siblings and parents are role models for children. If a child's parents smoke they are three times more likely to smoke themselves.

Experts say if you're parents smoke, drink, do drugs, use foul language, are abusive or engage in all sorts of other unsavory behavior...then you are at a higher risk of following in their footsteps and engaging in the same sort of behavior. Whether this is true or not, is irrelevant to me, because it isn't true for me. I am none of those things.

Because some young adults who just so happened to play video games in their life decided to be evil or were always evil does not indicate there is a link between video games anymore then it proves that these games somehow blurred the line between knowing right from wrong.

Frankly, I find this talk of desensitization and not being able to differentiate between real and unreal violence ridiculous and borderline offensive. We have overreacted to the point of absurdity and are subjecting our kids to outrageous reactionary behavior that avoids identifying the real cause.

"A 5-year-old girl was suspended from school earlier this week after she made what the school called a "terrorist threat." Her weapon of choice? A small, Hello Kitty automatic bubble blower. The kindergartner, who attends Mount Carmel Area Elementary School in Pennsylvania, caught administrators' attention after suggesting she and a classmate should shoot each other with bubbles. The kindergartner was ordered to undergo a psychological evaluation during her 10-day suspension, which was later reduced to two days." (Full Story here)

I grew up in a somewhat violent home, although the violence wasn't directed at me. We had many guns available and I saw my stepfather on more than one occasion use one to threaten people. Sure, they were being jerks, but they probably didn't deserve to have their life threatened. I had access to those guns, especially since I was home alone so often. I never needed anybody to tell me playing with them was wrong, or dangerous. I could play violent video games for hours on end, and when I put the controller down at the end of the day, I still knew the difference between right and wrong, just like I knew those guns in the next room over had the capability of killing. My level of reasoning, even as a young kid, wasn't diminished from playing video games.

Somebody could argue games from back then weren't as real or violent as they are now, and I'd agree the graphics have certainly come along way...but as I grew older and the games evolved, I also had a family of my own. My kids from a very young age played games that would probably cause most mothers in the PTA to cringe and Mr. Kolb to condemn my parenting technique. But I've done what I've seen so many other parents fail to do, and that is raise all of my kids to adulthood without the problems that many of them faced...heck, that I faced...as a kid growing up...all while playing video games as an everyday part of their life. Violent video games even.

(Daddy's Little Girl - Shoots Guns, Plays Violent Video Games - knows the difference)

I'm a grown man now, as if you couldn't have guessed. I've been in the military a long time and travelled the world over, including a lovely trip to Iraq. I've seen the worst this world has to offer, but I've also seen the best. And through it all, I've been a gamer the whole time...and to this day, I'm still amazed that video games tug at my heart and are able to touch me emotionally the way they do - the sign of a great game if you ask me.

I've been known to get emotional with events most would characterize as silly, like the time in Red Dead Redemption when I was trying to assist a lawman being attacked by bandits who turned on me and shot my horse dead. That broke my heart. He was my favorite horse that I had since I started the game. Heck, in Minecraft I usually grow wheat to make bread for food, because I don't like killing the cows and pigs for food. Even I think that one is ridiculous...but they are so cute I just can't bring myself to strike them down. I've even played video games with strong content that really kind of grieved my spirit. It did anything but confuse the line between real and fake...in fact, it reminded me of the sanctity of life and how to preserve it. Games like Spec Ops The Line, Call of Duty, Battlefield and Dead Space all had moments that really stopped me in my tracks because of the brutality displayed in the game. It reminded me to appreciate life and amplified the difference between right and wrong.

If you ask me, these games have the opposite affect that many of the politicians and those against them seem to think they do. Instead of desensitizing us, how about evaluating whether they sharpen the level of sensitivity we feel when we play these types of games.

I am proof your statistics are skewed, and I'm sure I'm not alone.

 

Comments
  • Very good blog Saint!

  • You're indeed not alone. I've played my share of violent games. My childhood may have consisted with many fun games like Mario and TMNT, but I was also raised with a game that many raised a controversy of: DOOM.

    I've played Rescue: The Embassy Mission, I've played DOOM, I've played the Golden Eye Games, I've played the Gears of War games, Call of Duty, GTA... how is it that videogames makes a person violent? There is no proof. While there are mindless idiots that actually perform actions that they see in videogames, the link between these two is quite simple: stupid people.

    Yes, I may have done stupid stunts like wrestling moves, or made Lego Pistols, or played Laser Tag or Paintball, but I do know the line between right and wrong. I know what I should never imitate and the things that I can imitate WITH a safe-to-moderate ambient. Do I like going to a shooting range? Maybe, but you don't see me shooting other people in the shooting range just because I like playing violent videogames.

    I play GTA, and I'm not stealing cars, doing drugs, killing others, etc. I don't really see the link between violence and videogames per se. Stupid people I can see, just not the reason why there's a lot of Videogame violence. It's just politics being politics.

    If they ever label videogames the cause of gun violence, then label me a murderer. Heck, if that actually ever happens, sent me to prison and sentence me with every case where a victim died in hands of a gun. Put me in jail for life and label me a "bad influence" then. Because honestly, I know I ain't wrong, but politics likes to brainwash people. Maybe brainwashing myself could just "make sense" into this whole case.
  • I couldn't agree with you more, but as I like to put it, "now that I've spent all this time playing Madden I'm ready to join training camp" I'll be seeing you all next year after coaching my team to a perfect record with 11 shut outs and scoring 101 points. Because truthfully that is the same level of absurdity that these politicians are claiming when they claim video games desensitize us, or violent movies, or television shows. Well I've got to get ready to go start my campaign for Mayor, if Sim City has taught me anything it's that roads have to lead out of the city and to avoid too much traffic at the hospital...
  • Another great blog sir. I agree with many of the points presented. I grew up in a household that was anti-violence, anti-war and that did not let me play my first FPS until I was 16. However, I have grown up and fully understood that my friends who played that game were not more violent than me because of the games that they played. I've even become a fan of some FPS games and I don't feel like I've become a more violent person because of them either. Now, where I disagree is in my presumption that you feel as if most video games make you more sensitive. I agree that some definately accomplish that goal. However, I do feel a bit de-sensitized playing some video games. I think that the key thing is that people are raised in an environment where they know the difference between right and wrong. I do not feel as if video games are a primary factor in this. Would I like to see American culture be less violent? Sure. But I know that it isn't the main cause of the problems that are occuring in today's society. Another point though is that violent media and violent games can play a larger role in kids who are young immigrants to the country. Now, before anyone gets furious at me, let me explain. I am a son of an immigrant to the country. I am muslim, and attend a mosque that has a large population of immigrants who have only been in this country for about 1-5 years. Many of these people have kids who are younger than 7 or 8 playing M rated games and listening to innapropriate music. Now, while I know that they are still good kids and are extremely unlikely to be criminals, I do see more examples of them become troubled teens than their white counterparts. This is because of a misunderstanding of American culture, and many of these well-intending families fall victim to people fully embracing the first thing they notice about a culture, whether or not it's positive. Again, I really hope I didn't offend anyone. It's just a perspective in my life that I've seen. I am a 2nd-generation American myself, and apologize in advance if what I said seems innapropriate.
  • Great blog like always Saint. I have been playing games for almost 30 years,  I really that old, and quite a few of the games I have playedave been violent. Those games never made me a violent person the violence around me did when i was younger, grown up since then though and still play violent games and not violent anymore so with that argument i should still be violent . Violence is what you choose not because of games but what you see around you. Anything else is a cop out to avoid personal responsibility .

  • I've been playing video games since I was quite little, I don't swear, I don't drink or do drugs, I can occasionally be violent but that's just with my brother. This violent video games making people violent just isn't true, if a video game makes someone violent, there is probably something wrong with that person.

    I would just like to add, and this isn't necessarily just video games, but I started watching the Walking Dead about a year ago, I got two episodes in and just stopped watching it because I couldn't take how much blood and gore was in it. Later on I kept hearing about how good the Walking Dead was, so I decided to give it another shot. I can now watch the Walking Dead and other violent movies/shows/video games no problem. While the Walking dead did desensitize me to blood and gore, I in no way would ever want to inflict this kind of damage on another individual.

    Also Saint, do you have children older than me? I feel so young now...
  • It's extremely weird to me how some people will try to examine someones behavior and moral standing through external sources. Are there ways to influence a persons thoughts and upbringing? Yes. However, placing the blame on just one or two things is too simple for what can influence a human being's complex mind.

    When did some of us forget that there have, and always will be things like violence. It doesn't mean we can't try for a better future, but placing the blame on anything but ourselves isn't really getting us anywhere. It's hard to put into words for me, my two cents.

    Also, I read the full report on that 5 year old child. All I have to say to that is, I'm glad I'm not in school in this day and age.
  • Perhaps one of the greater Ironies of this world; parents are irresponsible in the raising of their children and then wonder why their children turned out "bad". That is not to say that some can break the great chain. Thats the goal, really. (bout to get reeeeal existential here) breaking the chain of prior mistakes to forge the proper human experience in the name of honor and good.

    Forgive me if I make little sense, its four in the morning.

  • Statistics, as they exist today, mostly serve as easy propaganda. Statistics are also a favorite tool for manipulation. At the end of the day, this whole uproar probably is just about money. If they can find a way to impose special taxes or fees on video games, I would bet that all of the controversy will "conveniently" go away.
  • Very good blog. I am tired of people, who do not play video games, saying video games desensitize us, and cause us to commit acts of violence. They do not. People who commit acts of violence are going to, whether or not they have played video games.

    I have always loved video games. I've played all types. From very cute LittleBigPlanet and Super Mario 64 to Killzone, Resistance, Call of Duty, Dead Space, and so forth. I have never once had any thoughts about violence, in fact I actually abhor violence. Yet, all of these games, just like you said, have caused me to care about the story and characters. I get easily attached to characters in a game. I don't want anything bad to happen to them. If I was so desensitized from playing games, I do not believe I would care what happened to anyone within video games, yet I do.

  • I hesitate to disagree with people online, especially someone so universally liked, but I do have to disagree with some points of this excellently written blog. I read it last night and haven't responded until this morning so hopefully the time I spent thinking about it will help me come across clearly. I don't think there is a single honest person who can say that the fact that you don't follow the statistics is a bad thing. The fact that you play these games and have a good head on your shoulders is fantastic. I think the point of this blog is to point out that everyone is an individual, and we shouldn't judge people based on their circumstances. I cannot agree more. However, especially reading the comments, it seems that the point crosses a bit into the "it isn't a problem to me; ergo no problem" category, which is a bit fallacious. It seems there is a stigma that those people who do studies and come up with statistics are bad people trying to push a point. In honesty, most are people who see a possible connection, wonder "hey what's up with that?" and thoroughly test it. As someone who's spent many MANY hours studying these research studies, writing literature reviews about them, and setting up a few of my own, the research is, almost exclusively, incredibly sound. It may be offensive to you that these statistics exist, but the fact of the matter is that as far as we can tell they're true. It's not supposed to mean x=y, like sometimes it is taken as, but there is a correlation that passes scientific scrutiny. As for the video games are linked to violence debate, it seems that most people who play video games are just as biased as those who are pushing a different agenda, and have done about as much research. Saying "there is no evidence that video games desensitize us" is just as scientifically sound as saying "Doom caused Columbine." There is actually a general consensus among independent studies that violent media does (tentatively) correlate to aggression (though not necessarily violence). Again, I apologize for the disagreement, as I usually agree with most everything you say. I think that your original point is VERY good and something that we all need to remember, but somewhere between the delivery and receipt of the message the lines may have gotten crossed and the message extrapolated beyond its intent.
  • Hear, hear (especially) to your closing lines. This is one of my favorite posts you've ever written, Saint. And I think you should mail this to Kolb.

  • "It reminded me to appreciate life and amplified the difference between right and wrong."

    That line was huge. It is going on my wall in my office alone with this blog so my kids can read it. Great stuff Saint. Hope you had a great weekend.

  • I know some people who are very opinionated about video games. They really get on my nerves. They talk about the effects of violent video games and I jump in and say, "Well... I grew up playing violent video games" and they ALWAYS make excuses & either insist that the games now are having a greater effect because the graphics are more realistic or they insist that I'm the exception, not the rule. Also, they tend to subtly throw in that I had good parents & I immediately think, "Oh, so there are multiple factors, huh? It's not JUST the violent video games..."

    Grinds my gears...

  • I completely agree with your last comments there. Excellent writing.

  • "Heck, in Minecraft I usually grow wheat to make bread for food, because I don't like killing the cows and pigs for food. Even I think that one is ridiculous...but they are so cute I just can't bring myself to strike them down."

    Once I realized I could make shears to get wool from sheep without killing them, I felt like a monster. Also, one of these days I need to invite you GIO folks to my minecraft manor. You should see my wheat fields.

  • Hey Saint! There are many of us who agree with u. I for one, absolutely agree. Just because I play games like COD, MOH, Ghost Recon, or Max Payne 3 doesn't mean I want to kill someone.  I think that your closing lines were stated gracefully; that everyone that reads this or agree with you to some extent.

  • Simply put, Thank you Saint for all you do.

  • Saint, I just wanted to say that I have honestly never respected you more than at this moment. Video Games have been a part of my life since I was young, and one of my first games was the ever infamous Mortal Kombat. I played for hours and hours, but to this day I wouldn't consider myself violent. In fact video games have often served as an outlet for anger and aggression. Now the people who make the games that I love and to a lesser extent myself are under attack, because of shootings where the shooters may have possibly picked up a controller once in a while? I will never understand it.

    I agree that firmer restrictions should be placed on children buying these games. Children don't need to be able to virtually kill people if their parents think they can't handle it. I however am an adult and my entertainment choices are of no concern to the government or anyone else. I love gaming and these attempts to use it as a whipping boy for societies ills need to stop.

    Now I'm off to play MurderKill 3: The Murderingest. Why? Because I'm an Adult and this is still America. And Contrary to popular belief I know the difference between reality and fantasy.
  • Excellent Blog!

1 2 Next