The lights are on
Veteran Member - Level 11
Hey fellas, how would you like to play a video game that
features scantily clad men with their junk overstatedly modeled and partially
exposed? Yeah, I didn't think so.
I'm assuming if you're reading this then you consider
yourself a gamer. Truth be told, that is the only assumption I make. I don't
assume you're a male or female, white or black, or your console of choice is
the Xbox 360 or Playstation 3. And since we're being honest, I don't even
really care about these qualities. What I do care about is that I publish
something everybody who takes the time to read will find beneficial or at least
entertaining. And to achieve that goal it is imperative I treat you all equally
and fairly. I suppose one could argue the anonymity associated with the
Internet is conducive to accomplishing this - the less I know about you the
less likely I am to judge you. But that is only one variable. What happens when
I do get to know some of you like I have, especially when learning we might be
vastly different? Cats and Dogs oh my! The key is to treat everybody the same -
treat them the way you would want to be treated. That whole Golden Rule
There is an interesting discussion afoot in the world of
Twitter that has captured my attention as I try to disassemble the issue in an
effort to understand it. I know some of you are following the matter, and I
know some of you despise Twitter and are not. But the issue is one that realistically
affects us all, whether we're cognizant of it or not.
Why aren't there more
women working in the video game development industry?
Or for that matter,
Why aren't there more
women working in the video game industry?
Prior to being made aware of this issue, if you asked me why
there aren't more women working in the video game industry I probably would
have responded, "Maybe they just don't want to." I've heard quiet rumblings of
this issue before but never really any widespread claims from industry experts.
My real awareness of the issue started today after reading the Twitter posts
with the hashtag #1reasonwhy posted
by a number of women developers and their supporters listing their reasons why
the video game development industry doesn't boast higher female employment
numbers. The issue escalated and expanded its scope to include other
disciplines in the industry including video game journalism. I was rather
surprised to read some of the explanations and even more shocked this sort of
stereotyping still exists, especially in this particular industry.
Perhaps I've lived a sheltered life having been in the
military as long as I have. The military is one of the most diverse and
integrated organizations you'll ever find. I recall when I was in Iraq working
in a Network Operations Center, there were two supervisors managing the facility
- one worked days and the other worked mids (12 hour days, 7 days a week). The
two couldn't be more opposite including the fact one was female and the other
male; one was Army and the other Navy. Well, I was the Navy guy. My counterpart
and I were both equally qualified and capable of doing the job and we were both
given the opportunity to do it, but we were worlds apart in nearly every other
aspect. We had a completely different way of doing business, but at the end of
the day - mission accomplished. I think the organization benefited from having
that diversity. And by the way, her and I got along great and had mutual
respect for one another.
To hear that discrimination exists within the development
realm (and beyond) of our beloved video game industry doesn't make sense to me.
It's not that I doubt the sincerity of the claims, because I absolutely do,
especially after reading tweet after tweet where you can literally feel the
hurt, pain...and dare I say - betrayal from those affected. It's just that if
there is one industry where you would think freedom of expression and
creativity would surpass anatomy, it's the video game industry, or at least the
modern era instantiation of the industry. There was a time when gamers, and
developers for that matter, were perceived as these nerdy, socially inept
rejects. But come on, that was decades ago. We've moved well past that
perception, haven't we? Wasn't that debunked a long time ago when guys like
John Carmack and John Romero made it cool to be a gamer? With the percentage of
women gamers only slightly trailing that of men, and with the age gap ever
widening, defining what it is to be a gamer is nearly impossible and women
having a larger role in this industry is inevitable. It's happening now.
So, why does discrimination exist or more importantly...how
have we let this continue to exist?
Obviously there is no way I could tackle such a delicate and
deep issue in the confines of a single blog, but I can make a few casual
observations about the topic.
Well, first and foremost I guess we could take the
"plausible deniability" approach and say that since we weren't aware it was
going on it's not our fault. I'm going to be honest, as a gamer and a consumer
who purchases games, I couldn't tell you who was individually involved with
making the game I'm buying and playing (unless it's from Valve); certainly not
the male to female employment percentages for the publishers and/or developers
responsible for producing it.
Does that mean we have no responsibility in the matter? Well,
that's up for you to decide on an individual level. But how many of us would
scoff about buying clothes from Wal-Mart or any other manufacturer when
learning the items were mass produced in some sweatshop in a third world
country that forced its employees to work in harsh conditions for practically
no wages. Some would boycott the store all together; some might still shop at
the store but probably wouldn't speak very highly of it; and some wouldn't care
at all and continue shopping there.
Would you be
persuaded not to purchase a game if you knew the company responsible for making
it discriminated against women developers?
I guess what I'm getting at, as the end user of these
products we have the least visibility on the scope and severity of the issue.
If you (the women video game developers who have experienced discrimination) want
our support, we need to be informed...we need to know what companies, or even
better, what individuals are guilty of this behavior. Otherwise, how else are
we to respond? Obviously coming out and speaking against a particular
individual or organization can be a death sentence to one's career, but as
previously mentioned, the anonymity of the Internet should afford advocates for
this cause to set up shop and inform the gaming community of offenders. Surely
they're not all corrupt, right? Bottom line, we need to know who. As a proud
father of a daughter who is very much into video gaming, I'd like to know if
the individuals in the industry that I hold in such high regard and financially
support by buying their products are going to give my daughter a fair shake and
an equal opportunity should she pursue a career in the industry.
Compounding the issue is the double standards often
associated between the sexes.
Without naming names, I can think of a certain female video
game developer I follow on Twitter who used to have a profile pic of her posing
rather provocatively in practically nothing holding a video game controller. I
thought, "real classy lady" and dismissed the picture, but really I think it
kind of tarnished the image of this particular person.
Many of the ladies commenting on the #1reasonwhy share how
they've been treated and cite some specific examples. It's a shame this has occurred
but not all of us male/guy/man gamers (and I'm guessing developers) are guilty
of inappropriate behavior. I'd venture to say that the guilty are the minority
(they're just the most vocal), that most of us are decent and openly acknowledge
that women are just as good of gamers as we are, just as active as we are and I'm
guessing, just as good at developing them too. I look at some of my favorite
video games and the women who were involved with their development. And not
just "involved" but leading the way.
Amy Hennig's work on the Uncharted series is nothing short
of spectacular. It's my understanding she led the team responsible for the game
in addition to being the writer. This game is without a doubt one of the
greatest games ever created.
Kim Swift is another proven woman in the video game
development industry. With games like Portal and the Left for Dead series in
her portfolio, who can argue with her impressive resume? I'm sure there are plenty
of male developers who wished they could say they worked on Portal.
Anyway, just like there are plenty of examples of men being
pigs and treating women badly, there is no denying that some women, even women
in the video game industry, exploit their features and femininity. You can't
(or shouldn't) argue against sexism and femininity in one breath and then turn
around and flaunt it for your benefit. If you do then you shouldn't expect to
be taken seriously. I'd say like the men, this behavior is the exception and
not the norm...but it still happens. And not just in the video game industry but
in nearly every industry. This is a prevalent problem permeating throughout our
society. I think it will eventually fix itself, at least in the realm of the
video game industry, over time as the equilibrium between male and female
gamers and developers equalizes.
Finally, I think the root cause of this problem...all problems
for that matter is money. I've blogged about this before, but the video game
industry is a business; and businessmen and women want to make money. Lots of
money. If that means sacrificing standards to turn a profit, so be it. I'm not
saying it's right, only that it's the truth...or at least my perception of the
truth. It's why we see booth babes littered around the floor of E3 and why we
see video games exploiting women get slammed by reviewers but still advertised
on their website. It's the power of the almighty dollar hard at work. The very
existence of some games survive off of the exaggerated representation of women,
just look at the Dead or Alive series. I doubt there are very many women
pounding on the door of Team Ninja looking for work. I'm just guessing though...I
could be wrong. But seriously, look at a game like Rockstar's Grand Theft Auto
series which is known for having some rather edgy content. I'm not saying it isn't
real or isn't right, but I could see how there might be conflict with women
developers working on that sort of content and hesitation by the studio to bring
them aboard. Again, just guessing.
In closing, I doubt most of the ladies tweeting #1reasonwhy
will happen across this little ole blog of mine, but I've been surprised before
with some names who have read my blogs...so in the off chance it happens...
Ladies, know there are gamers out there who appreciate you
and your contributions to the video games we love to play; sympathize with the challenges
you face working in a male dominated industry, and hope you find peace and joy
chasing your dreams and turning them into reality...
One should treat other
gamers as one would like other gamers to treat oneself.
Peace, love and Donkey Kong.
I really hope the industry isn't really all that sexist. I'd be more than happy to start a Videogame Company with women. Hell, why not start now with my RPG Maker project? Onwards with the search!
Good blog, Saint! As usual, you brought a good topic to talk about.
Good blog. Personally, I wouldn't purchase a game if I knew the developer had a bad reputation in terms of sexism. It's something that shouldn't be tolerated, but sadly even today throughout many industries this is still the case. I do firmly believe that progress is being made, it may just be painfully slow.
Very nice post. I've also been watching this evolve in Twitter (mostly through the feeds of Mattie Brice and Brendan Keogh) with some interest.
I think one of the major points which was highlighted was that the majority of male gamers and developers were indeed "good sorts" but, and it's a big but (cue Sir Mix-A-Lot joke), to realign any of these sorts of acts of discrimination relies on those "good sorts" doing more than recognising the problem but actually acting upon it.
I think the other argument that I'd present is that game development industry is not just a business but also an artistic endeavour. With that comes the burden of representation of reality and all the baggage that comes with it. I know it's an argument that has been presented before in terms of other media forms but I thought it was worth rehashing as I think it's even more relevant with games being the cutting edge of representation in the media.
Either way good job in bring the issue to the wider masses. I'm a long time reader but (cue cliché) first time poster.
Side Note : Have you checked out Keogh's close textural reading of Spec-Ops: The Line, "Killing Is Harmless"? It's really well worth a read even if the game was seen as quite generic.
OK. First off, great post. Second, the video game industry is still very young. Women being discriminated against, and exploited, goes far beyond it.
Don't get me wrong here, sex sells. It always has, and I doubt we will see a change in this for a long time. Although, I agree that women shouldn't be held back in their artistic prowess, or in their presence in the industry, just because of their gender. If a woman wants to flaunt her femininity, so be it.
There are all kinds of colors of folks in the world. Being as how you've served in the military, I'm sure you have seen your share, so I won't waste your time with the obvious.
I believe you already posted the solution in your blog. It will take time for gender equality to fully integrate into the industry, and for gamers, to realize what's going on and make their voice heard that it's time for a change.
Sorry if that didn't make sense. Haven't written seriously for a long time.
Great blog, keep writing.
Excellent blog. In terms of sexism, and most other -isms, many people believe that simply given enough time, they will go away. But, in the words of Martin Luther King Jr. "Such an attitude stems from a tragic misconception of time, from the strangely irrational notion that there is something in the very flow of time that will inevitably cure all ills. Actually, time itself is neutral; it can be used either destructively or constructively. More and more I feel that the people of ill will have used time much more effectively than have the people of good will." It takes more than time. It takes good people standing up for their beliefs and doing something.
That is all.
Great blog Saint ! I wish the industry wasn't so sexist towards women. I mean they do make up half of our games !
Excellent blog Saint, I couldn't have said it better myself. Bravo good sir bravo!
Great blog. This is such a difficult issue, and yet I can't believe anyone would actually believe in sexist crap. You'd have to be brain-dead to buy into that stuff.
girls r lame they cnt play games men r duh 1337 awesome onez.
joking aside I think sexism is a incredibly large problem in this day and age not only in the video game industry but in almost every type of workplace. I just went through a sociology class for school not that long ago and also check around online a little bit about this very thing. It's been proven that women make less then men in everything and are usually looked down upon in just about every profession, except something like nursing. I think that's incredibly stupid. Men and women are pretty much equal when it comes to just about everything. Granted there are a few things that, yes, they probably wouldn't be good as men at, such as construction or heavy manual labor type stuff for obvious reasons to do with how their body's are. When I think of this type of stupid sexism crap I only think of how it is so much like slavery. Granted they are not being forced to do stuff or to that extreme but they are generally looked down upon and "inferior" to men and thus, get less money and other things than men. If you think about, slaves even were allowed to vote before women were allowed to vote. Hopefully one day sexism won't be such a problem but for we can pretty much only wait and hope for the best.
Great blog Saint. I've been following a number of gaming women on twitter, and it was rather amazing watching as a few tweets turned into a few thousand.
I did one blog on female characters in fighting games, and I've been meaning to do another long those lines. I'm thinking of reaching out to some of the bigger companies out there and asking to see what % of women they have working for them; some companies (or at last game series) have reputations of creating terrific female characters, and many times it's because they have women in higher up positions fighting for those changes to be made. Elena from Uncharted or Trishka from Bulletstorm are good exmaples of what we get when women have a say in how games get made, and I'm really curious to see who else is following that example.
This is such a hard issue to tackle. And really, the treatment of women in the video games industry is just another facet of the human tendency to discriminate. So the, I think you have to think about what are the root causes of discrimination and if those things can be addressed.
I'll just say this. In my life, I have found that racism, sexism, nationalism and most other "isms" are merely the byproducts of fear, ignorance and propaganda.
I've known former skinheads who said they once identified themselves as one in order to survive while incarcerated. I've met had gay co-workers and friends who said that they didn't think gays should marry or didn't care about the issue. I've had black friends who didn't get upset about the use of the N word, and sometimes even found it amusing. I've both asian and hispanic friends who spoke in a very derogatory fashion about their own race. And... I've had female friends and co-workers who hate feminism and feel that the women's lib movement actually made things worse for women.
Now how do you address all of that???
My point is, in order to tackle an issues as large as this, there hs to be an organized and unified collection of people determined to change it. The French and American Revolutions could have never been fought or won if there was no solidarity and the ability to agree on who was the enemy and what needed to be fixed. That's my take.
I don't know why, but I can never think of a reply for these types of blogs, I certainly agree with you, but I just don't know what to say. I sure do hope women get treated more fairly in the games industry, they could become great developers (or writers) just as easily as men.
it's sad to see sexism in the gaming industry. It's sad to see any kind of discrimination anywhere, really. While it's bad now, time will change how it's perceived. Always does, always will.