The lights are on
Veteran Member - Level 14
Note: Due to the nature
of this blog, there will be spoilers.
of the greatest criticisms about Mass Effect 3 was its apparent contradiction
of the previous themes the lore had established by relying on one of the most
overused science fiction conventions: the Crucible, an uberpowerful weapon
capable of destroying the Reapers. While others chalked the use of this trope
up to poor writing, others criticized it for another reason: the belief that a
victory without the Crucible was possible. There are those among us, of course, who believe this is naturally impossible, such as Chris Shepard: "Conventional victory against the reapers? Lol, dude, you're going up
against hand cannons with a peashooter, the reapers were designed to be
unstoppable, and that's just what they were. I was fully expecting a 'loophole' ending, and ME delivered a great one."
The Reject ending, what I consider
to be a true "science fiction" ending, didn't support this either, yet countless
Mass Effect fans continue to debate the merits of either side of this position.
After a lot of deliberation, I've come up with a conclusion myself: in spite of
the near invincibility the Reapers were bestowed plot-wise, a conventional
victory is possible, and here's why.
This blog is nothing more than a
hypothetical thought experiment that looks at the strengths and weaknesses of a
possible victory against the Reapers. I'd welcome anyone to critique it and
argue against it; that's what good debates are made of. Note also that a "conventional" victory simply refers to one in which the Crucible is not used. It doesn't imply that a battle against the Reapers would be easy or simplistic; it simply takes into account the myriad resources the galaxy had available.
examine the key advantages the Reapers have: there are several types that have
been recognized, such as Processors, Transports, Destroyers, and finally
Capital Ships, the last of which are the gigantic and powerful Reapers on the
scale of Sovereign and Harbinger. According to the codex, Processors are in
essence the ships that harvest various races for their genetic material - nearly
two million humans are harvested daily during the Reaper invasion of Earth by
merely about 200 of these ships - while Transports are used to carry husks and
similar indoctrinated during invasions; both of these forms of Reapers are
unique in that they are not sapient, instead controlled by other Reapers.
the most common form of Reaper that is encountered during the events of Mass
Effect 3, comprise the majority of the Reaper fleet and respectively are
created from the genetic material of the majority of the species harvested
during their invasions. Then, there are Capital Ships, lumbering titans that
are unique in that each is created entirely from a chosen civilization during
each cycle of destruction; these are effectively the chief executors of the
Reaper population, and for sake of argument, let's assume one is created each
time. Judging by the oldest known Reaper, dating back about one billion years,
this would mean that no less than 20,000 Capital Ships exist, and when factored
in with remaining Reaper forces, I'd estimate that no less than half a million Reapers
exist in total, and it could be innumerably more; this is entirely speculation
In addition to their intimidating numbers and immense scale, Reapers have the key advantage of
being extremely advanced in contrast to the civilizations they're invading;
their ability to reach Council space so quickly after the events of Mass Effect
2 - several months - suggests that their FTL drives are incredibly superior to
any ship known to the races in the current galaxy, and their strongest ships
have superior kinetic barriers, powerful guns, and precise targeting abilities
that allow them to make work of entire fleets without much trouble. Judging by
the number of destroyed fuel stations that players encounter while exploring
Reaper-infested territory, Reapers also seem to operate with an energy system
far beyond organic comprehension as well. Their strongest forces can shield themselves up to three simultaneous attacks from dreadnought-class ships before being taken down.
indoctrinating powers of Reapers allow them to easily create sleeper units
that can infiltrate and sabotage the plans of any resistance - this was the
primary reason that the Protheans failed to finish the Crucible; legions of
husks and other grotesque Reaper creations supply the bulk of the ground forces
used to overwhelm the areas they invade. In addition to this comes the
durability of their strongest ships, which take on average four dreadnoughts to
be destroyed. These advantages, however, do not compare to their greatest
hundreds of millions of years experience exterminating galactic civilization,
with a methodology that is crude, efficient, and has nonetheless become an art
in itself. As the creators of the Citadel, they have effectively designed a
central location that has been chosen as the nexus of galactic order by
advanced organics since its inception. This has allotted them a key strategic
advantage in that they are often able to topple the galaxy's primary leaders within
one fell swoop and set the rest of the adjoining civilizations into confusion
and disarray. As creators of the Mass Effect Relays, controlled via the
Citadel, the machine race has unquestionable control over the maneuvering
capabilities of the resistance and can deactivate the Relays to isolate the
resistance and systematically annihilate them. Thus, when one considers all
these advantages - and many others, I'm sure - defeating the Reapers without
Space Magic or some plot device seems highly improbable.
said "improbable," but not impossible.
several notable weaknesses the Reapers have when one takes the events depicted
throughout the series into consideration, which I will delve into before
offering my own strategy to defeat the Reapers conventionally. Firstly, it's
evident based upon their approach that the Reapers' primary means of action has always
focused on the same objectives, instead of having any innovation: surprise, infiltration and sabotage (usually through indoctrination), and destruction of resources, followed by a sweep of
powerful units in overwhelming numbers. With technology as advanced as theirs as their primary advantage, in addition to indoctrination, one could say it's pretty obvious why the Reapers have never changed their methodology; countless cycles have shown that the
battle against the Reapers naturally isn't going to be one dictated purely by
numbers, but by the subtle value those numbers have. However, the statement is two-folded if we consider the lesson the Reapers learned through the loss of Saren.
We've only seen the Reapers change their strategy because of the setbacks put into motion to the strategy they'd honed so immaculately, suggesting that they probably don't have much experience conducting war without this measure. In contrast, the
galaxy currently has a wealth of different resources and military strategies to
draw from. Space-age technology also ensures we have the production power
necessary to successfully compensate for any units lost, provided the resources are available, and even the ability to manufacture stronger ones; the much-needed dreadnoughts, for instance. Imagine what we're able
to accomplish in the future, especially with the technological expertise we've
developed through our contact with the other Council races! Quite a few treaties would probably need to be signed or amended, but for the sake of the Galaxy it's safe to say - as Shepard has proven - that some grudges and disagreements can be set aside temporarily.
On the other hand, the Reapers have little need of our natural resources, and instead are quick to demolish them to impede any resistance. Nonetheless, the Reapers rely on sentient organisms to reproduce and create new forces, as well as conduct the majority of their warfare, a limited but essentially infinitely reusable resource given the ability to indoctrinate their
enemies, if not the primary need: they most likely wouldn't be capable of matching our production rate otherwise, let alone surviving without organics and synthetics as a proxy. Yet, all this reveals is that the Reapers, while still daunting, aren't as invincible as they