Switch Lights

The lights are on

What's Happening

I Couldn't Play a Game Like That...

 

I don't know about you, but I'm pretty opinionated about game genres. In the past, I've been pretty set on what genres I don't play.

 

"I don't play RPGs."

 

"I don't play turn-based strategy games."

 

"I don't play QTE games."

 

When I was younger, I played Final Fantasy: Mystic Quest on Super Nintendo, and it had turn-based combat. Overall, I enjoyed the game, but I wasn't itching to play more games like it. At some point, I decided, "I don't like turn-based games." During one of the camping trips I went on with my friends, I recall having a conversation about turn-based games. My friend Jordan is a fan of the Final Fantasy and Star Ocean franchises, and he defended the genre. But several of us (including myself) were very vocal about how dumb turn-based combat is. We made it very clear that we'd much rather play a game with live-action combat.

 

However...

 

This past year, I heard a lot of buzz about XCOM. There seemed to be a lot of excitement for the return of this franchise. After the game released, I noticed that it had a metascore of 90 on Metacritic. I listened to the Game Informer editors talk about it on the GI podcast, and it sounded like a lot of fun. I knew the game had turn-based combat, but I was really itching to try something new and the alien invasion setting of XCOM was appealing to me. I'm about 30 hours into that game so far and holy crap, I'm enjoying it. I guess turn-based combat isn't so dumb after all...

XCOM doesn't have the same type of turn-based combat as Final Fantasy, but it's still turn-based and not something I found particularly exciting in the past. XCOM took my opinion of turn-based strategy and completely blew it out of the water. This game is intense!

 

In 2010, my brother-in-law told me I should try the demo for Heavy Rain. He was impressed with the demo and thought the game was interesting. Personally, I wasn't impressed. I thought, "This game is dumb." Investigating the crime scene was somewhat interesting, but the gameplay seemed really boring to me and the game seemed very slowly paced. Sometime after that, I watched a video where Dan Ryckert's dad played it and after that, the game not only seemed dumb to me, but laughably bad. Dan's dad makes fun of every game he plays, but his banter added to my opinion of the game. 

That same year, Telltale Games released a Back to the Future game. Initially, I was really excited for this until I heard it was an "episodic" game. This was the first I had heard of games being released in episodes. I had my own opinion of this concept. "That's dumb. I don't want to follow a game that's released that way. I don't have enough patience to wait for the next episode! HAHA!"

 

However...

 

Telltale Games released the Walking Dead game this past year. Like the Back to the Future game, it was released in episodes. I ignored the game for a few months as it didn't sound like the kind of game I'd want Walking Dead to be anyways (let alone the fact that it was episodic.) I was hoping for something more like the TV show than the comic, and I was wanting it to be a 3rd person shooter. I really enjoyed Red Dead Redemption's Undead Nightmare, and I basically wanted to experience being Rick Grimes in a similar way. To my surprise, the Walking Dead game received a metascore of 94 on Metacritic, and I saw a lot of people talking about the game on Twitter. After all the episodes were released, I finally decided I should play this game (it helped that I got it for 50% off on Xbox Live!) I've played the 1st episode, and I'm really impressed so far. As much as I hate to admit it, the gameplay is a lot like Heavy Rain. I guess QTE games aren't so dumb afterall...

I'm a big fan of the Walking Dead, so I may not have bought a game like this otherwise, but I wasn't guaranteed to like it either. Like I said, I had originally desired something else entirely for a Walking Dead game.

 

I've been strongly opinionated about RPGs for a long time. I've particularly been a critic of JRPGs like Final Fantasy since the series moved to 3D. I've had several people tell me the stories are great, but they just don't appeal to me. Like Pokemon, 3D Final Fantasy games are something I refuse to try. Even when western RPGs started getting rave reviews, like Bethesda's Fallout 3, I was reluctant to play games in that genre. I tried Fallout 3 at my brother-in-law's house, and I was annoyed with how much stuff there was to collect. There was so much random stuff to pick-up, like silverware. I became over-encumbered and was advised to drop some stuff. This went against my video game instincts, which was to collect everything that was obtainable. I was also not a fan of the "conversations". I hated that part, I just wanted to get to the action! I walked away from the game thinking it was dumb. There was some combat towards the end of the part I played, but I was still set on saying I wasn't interested.

 

However...

 

In 2011, I saw a lot of buzz about Skyrim. After the first few trailers for the game, I was curious about this title - it looked awesome. Especially after becoming a fan of fantasy post-Lord of the Rings, I was anxious to play a game in this setting. And the dragons... man, those dragons really appealed to me. I questioned myself for months - "Am I really going to buy this game? It's an RPG. I don't like RPGs." But I told myself to shut-up because the game looked too epic to pass-up. The Elder Scrolls V was basically my first 3D RPG, and I thoroughly enjoyed it. I'm sure this doesn't surprise anyone who's familiar with the Elder Scrolls games, but I've put more hours into Skyrim than any other game I have for Xbox 360. I guess RPGs aren't so dumb afterall...

I was very torn about playing Skyrim. I'm so glad I went for it - it was everything I wanted it to be and more. I'm still not a huge fan of conversation trees, but I've gotten used to them.

 

There have been plenty of times that I've said, "I couldn't play a game like that." But as the above examples have shown, that's not necessarily true. I've discovered that I actually like more genres than I think I do.

What about you? Have you had any games appeal to you that were different than the types of games you're used to playing? Have you had a game change your opinion about a genre you were previously not a fan of?

 

Comments
  • Funny, I think my own experience has been pretty much a mirror-image of yours, only flipped the other way. I'm a huge fan of RPGs, and have never much been into strictly action-oriented games. I've generally been rather set in my ways, too, but lately I have started to branch out a bit more. I actually chronicled one such experience (with Half-Life 2) in a blog a few months ago: http://www.gameinformer.com/blogs/members/b/quasiconundrum_blog/archive/2012/08/30/noob-39-s-eye-view-half-life-2-and-the-first_2d00_person-shooter.aspx (Not to toot my own horn; I just think it's interesting how similar, yet reversed, our experiences have been.) :)
  • You could say I had a similar experience, except with game ratings. I was pretty innocent, and(now I'm legally able to buy them) didn't buy/play M games, at all. But then Dead Space 2 came out...and well, I hopped on board the "play games you're "not" suppose to play train, and that year, I bought and played through every Half-Life, Borderlands, Fallout 3, yada yada.
  • Hmm, yeah it's weird, sometimes when you don't really click with a game, you click with a sequel.
    Like GTA3. Nice game, interesting mechanics, but it completely failed to really draw me in.
    Then Vice City came out, I gave it a reluctant try, and fell completely in love with it. And, it's pretty much the exact same game...
    Gaming's weird...
  • I think many people in the world say something quite similar to this along the lines of "I will never play video games". If you have Angry Birds or Cut the Rope, you are playing video games. I find it funny how there are so many little things like this where someone is dead set on never playing anything from a certain genre of games (or movies or tv shows etc) and every once in a while something comes along that they just happen to check out and it just happens to be that genre that they hate/don't like/never thought they would play it. I always keep a pretty open mind when it comes to games. I know I don't like sports games or most music games, but I'm not adverse to ever playing them. I have played plenty of fun games from random genres I thought I would never play. There is always a gem in each genre even if you dislike it. Fun little blog. Keep up the fun stuff.
  • Heh, I actually have a completely different experience, having had the advantage of growing up on a whole variety of game types. Point and click adventures like Myst, 3D platforming in Alice, my first RPG in Neverwinter Nights, and the original Halo as my first (exciting) first person shooter (I don't really count Midimaze). I may have a running grudge match going with platformers, but as it seems you've discovered, you can miss out on some excellent experiences if you restrict yourself based solely on genre, especially with many games in recent years blending elements from varied genres together. It'll be interesting to see where genres go as technology changes.
  • Before I joined GIO, I loathed FPS games. Now, I rank some in my favorite games ever. Killzone and Crysis are among them. I'm a picky guy. If it wasn't for someone comparing XCOM to a game I absolutely loved, I would never have purchased it. I'm not really a Strategy game guy, but XCOM pulls it off wonderfully. Its almost like giving a child a V8 to make sure. They get their vegetable servings... trickery.
  • I'm not one for racing or fighting games.Of course I enjoy Mario Kart and Smash Bros. but the majority of the titles in those genres don't appeal to me. I've tried Forza, GTA, Street Fighter, and so on but I just don't enjoy them very much.
  • I feel the same way about racing and fighting games. I can drive a car in real life so why do it in a game, and I suck at fighting games so I tend to avoid those.
  • I was really resistant to The Walking Dead as well. I've played it through twice, and, though I'm still unsure what I think about it in terms of its "gameness," I can honestly say it was a rich experience. I'm glad I put my reservations behind me in order to give it a shot.
  • Mod
    I fell out of interest in the racing genre, but Most Wanted reignited the passion. TWD really helps to broaden our potential understandings of what "games" are, and while the story isn't as varied as Heavy Rain was, I did like it overall, minus a few considerable pet peeves.
  • I used to be really bad about sticking to one or two genres. For awhile, I nearly played nothing but racing games. Then I stuck to first person shooters for awhile. Which eventually led me to playing Fallout 3, which got me into The Elder Scrolls, which got me into RPGs (a genre I used to not care much for), which encouraged me to play other games I normally wouldn't. I'm pretty thankful that I played Fallout lol.
  • I used to say i hate RPG's then came KOTOR, love sci fi RPG's still can't get into the fantasy ones though. Same goes for the MMORPG genre. Still not a fan of zombie games though and definitely not the zombie dlc for FPS, can't stand them. Use to not like PC gaming then got hooked on the Total War franchise and bought a PC that can run the new ones and love it. So just shows as we try new things what we find we enjoy.

  • I try to keep an open mind about genres I don't play much.

    I like the new Fallout games so I bought the old ones. I wanted to like them so bad but I couldn't get into the turn based combat. I just want to blast stuff without strategy. If the combat was more diablo w/guns I'd put so many hours in.

    I can't play stealth games either. Manhunt is the only game I made it through without wanting to get caught. Dishonored and Deus Ex HR, I only took anybody out with stealth if it was a total gimme.

  • Wow, the last time I was that close minded about games I was 10 years old. Glad to see you stopped shutting yourself off from great games for silly reasons, no offense.
  • ...I never really try to exclude genres until I've at least tried them a few times, and am always open to seeing if I can be proven wrong. Not every game from every genre appeals to me but... you really made yourself sound a bit more closed-off from new experiences outside of a certain space.

    The only genres I'm most likely to be turned off by are MMOs with hotbars and DOTAs. The latter just breeds hatefulness and often they have unbalanced gameplay. MMOs with hotbars on the other hand... trying to beat Guild Wars pretty much broke my patience for hitting buttons 1-8. I've tried playing TOR, and it's mildly better but... bah I just prefer having my own skill, rather than numbers, do the work. But then I found Warframe and Vindictus, where skill did matter. Similarly, I found Forge, which I think is the closest thing to a DOTA that I have actually enjoyed consistently.

    So yeah, it's fine to not be into a genre. But don't deny it of any credibility just because you played one game in the genre. The sheer amount of games out amongst indie and AAA devs allow for so many different experiences and twists on the same basic concepts that it's about impossible at this point to say a certain genre can't be entertaining to someone unless they utterly hate every aspect about it.

    I hope that makes sense... I apologize if it doesn't, I've been a bit tired these past few days.