The lights are on
Subscriber - Level 4
One of the darker rumors surrounding Microsoft’s new hardware is that it won’t allow players to buy games used. While this is probably nothing more than speculation, it would be unfortunate to see Microsoft make this decision, because it would irrevocably damage the system’s accessibility.
I have given reasons why used games are important for game accessibility in brief in other articles, but in order to understand the issue fully, you really need to delve into the issue of why used games are inherently more accessible than new ones. There are two reasons, both are deeply embedded in the issue of financial accessibility.
First, used games are cheaper. For a lot of disabled gamers who are on limited incomes, the only way they can enjoy hot game titles is if they pick them up used. Also, the longer someone waits, the more likely they are to hear that a game is inaccessible. Therefore, it is not only cost effective, but also incredibly useful for determining a game’s accessibility if a player waits and decides to buy it used. For example, in my own gaming career, I was incredibly surprised when I heard how forgiving Metal Gear Rising: Revengeance was. I had not originally planned on playing it because from all the footage shown at E3 and other conferences the game looked to require too many rapid button presses. However, as I shopped in GameStop for something to rate for DAGERS, the clerk told me how easy he thought the controls would be for my disability and sold me a used copy. So not only was I able to get the game at a lower price, because I waited to get a used copy, it came with a recommendation from a sales clerk who knew both the game and my physical ability. So there was much less of a risk when I purchased the game.
But the bigger issue is that used games typically have return policies that are much more lax than new games. A non-accessibility illustration of this was Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic 2. I had eagerly purchased it only to find out that it was not playable on my system. The bad news was, I was out sixty bucks because my hardware failed. When speaking in terms of accessibility, instances like this happen much more often. For example, Medal of Honor: Warfighter had so many barriers in it that I couldn’t progress past the fourth stage, no matter how hard I tried and even with the help of a friend. But because I bought the game new, there was nothing the sales clerk could do except apologize. By contrast, if I or players like me are able to buy games used (at GameStop, for example), there is usually an extended period of time in which the game can be played and returned without losing any money. As a result, players have the option to try games, and if a title proves to be inaccessible, they can simply return it for a full refund.
The bottom line is this: Buying a game when you have a disability is always a risk—one that many disabled people can’t afford to take very often. So when they do, they really need to have the option of buying used games so that the risk of buying a game that they physically can’t handle is greatly lessened.
For more articles on game accessibility, please visit DAGERS, or find us on Facebook or @dagersystem.
I agree that it would be a huge loss for XBOX if they didnt allow used games. Also I find myself at stores like GameStop more often because they allow me to buy older games that I really wanted to play but never did. Nice blog.
Great blog as usual. Thanks for giving us without disabilities an opportunity to understand those who are disabled better with each blog that you write.
I can't wait for more details about both upcoming consoles. I am curious if there is an end run around the announcements that used games are not blocked and EA's recent decrying of the online pass. Something is fishy. Personally, if all games provided demos that let me test the gameplay for my needs. Those initial moments searching menus for accessibility features are quite stressful. Nice blog.
Great blog. I think I read one of your blogs before and it brought the control barriers of disabled gamers to my attention, which is something that I had never thought of before. Once again you come at the topic and in a way that I would never have thought of writing about, yet it is on my mind every time I visit the game store.
Please don't take this the wrong way, but I can sort of compare this to when I am buying games for my 6 year old. He can't press buttons really fast yet, so we've come across a few games (Ice Age... kids stuff) in which he just can't get past parts of the game without help from myself or my wife. Good blog!
Just until recently, I used to only buy brand new games. However, as money has become harder to come by, I've started buying more used games instead. Once you realize $60 can buy you 3 six month old games it's hard to go back to buying new games. Also, game prices are dropping very quickly lately.