Switch Lights

The lights are on

5 Reasons You Should Buy a Smart Phone (And Not the 3DS/Vita)

First of all, I have momentous news. I finally got a smart phone. For years I've been stuck with Sprint, a notoriously sh*tty cell phone provider. I want to dump them and switch to Verizon for the iPhone, but Sprint is just too good at being really cheap. My phone contract is about half of what it would cost at Verizon.

However, Sprint finally did something right and released the HTC Evo 4G, basically the off-brand Android version of the iPhone. And let me just say, it is fantastic. Just in the few weeks I've been using and loving it, a certain truth has become more and more clear. With phones like the Evo and iPhone, who needs handheld consoles? It may not be something we hardcore gamers wish to admit, but it's true. Seriously, there is absolutely no reason to buy a 3DS or Vita if you have a good phone, and here's a few reasons why.

(For the purposes of this discussion, “mobile” refers to games for phones. “Handheld games” are those for the 3DS and Vita)

#1- Mobile games are better

Although they were pretty awful in the distant past (you know... 2006), mobile games have already surpassed handheld games. Mobile games are not only exponentially cheaper than their handheld counterparts, they're just as creative and entertaining. Equal entertainment for a far lower price equals better value. Plus, the Apple and Android App Stores aren't dominated entirely by Angry Birds (they split it with Angry Birds Seasons). There are also a host of other beautifully designed games like Cut the Rope, Peggle, World of Goo, and Doodle Jump. Mobile phones and especially the iPhone have built up a massive library of good games over the past couple years, easily enough to compete with handhelds.

Then there's the stereotype that mobile games are shallow, five-minute affairs that require no skill and a lack of brain activity from the player. The truth is that while those apps do exist, they are greatly outsold by the genuinely well-made ones. The best-selling mobile games like Geometry Wars and Infinity Blade are just as complex as handheld games. The complexity and sublime addictiveness of apps like Peggle and Civilization Revolution stand as testaments to just how good mobile games have become. My phone used to be only crappy Tetris ports, but now my iPod has a Civ game on it (!). Words cannot describe just how addictive Civ Rev is, especially when you can play it anywhere.

#2- A handheld console is unnecessary baggage

Quick, what do you have in your pockets? Don't answer that, I don't want to know. But I'm guessing at least one of the objects is a phone. Most people have cell phones because, well, you need them for communication or business or just setting up a group Minecraft session. Cell phones are darn useful for communicating with other people.

Man, life before cell phones sucked.

Now, what about a 3DS or Vita? That's one more thing to carry with you, and it can't call Grandma. I don't like walking around with my pockets stuffed full of crap. Nobody thinks “Boy, my pockets sure are empty. I'd better fill them with something heavy. If only I'd brought my antique anchor collection!” You have to carry a phone, but you really don't need a Vita. It can't text people, which brings me to my next point...

#3- A phone does so much more than a handheld console

One of the hallmarks of the modern smart phone is multitasking, the ability to do multiple things with one device. Just looking at my phone's home screen, I can see my mobile comic book reader, GPS, web browser, Kindle e-reader, and movies. I like to put my DVDs on my phone to watch in the car. Which of those functions is on a 3DS or Vita?

I'm reading this for the second time. Favorite. Comic. Ever.

Nobody lives in a void. I don't just play games, I also browse Cracked, read Engadget's RSS feed, periodically check GIO User Blogs, and watch episodes of A Game of Thrones that I missed. Handheld consoles can't do any of that, and even their web browsers are awkward to use. Remember what internet was like on the original PSP? Shudder...

The reason I use my phone more than any game console is because it's so much more potent than a console. I do things other than gaming, and my phone lets me do that easily.

Seriously, this show is like the gritty reboot of Lord of the Rings.

#4- Netflix

Just... Netflix. It's the greatest thing ever, and it's on your phone, not the 3DS or Vita. Enough said.

#5- Phones can do hardcore gaming too

For me, the one discovery that really sealed my opinion of phones' dominance was in, of all places, the Android App Store. After a quick search, I found a SNES emulator. It's an app that lets you play SNES games right there on your phone. After extensive use, I can attest that it works, and it is awesome. Now I can play classics like A Link to the Past and Super Street Fighter II right there on my phone. After those, I might replay Chrono Trigger. How cool is that?

I never play JRPGs, but man this game is awesome.

For background, my first console as a kid was the Game Boy Color. Thus, I grew up right at the end of the N64 era. Thus, I never got to play anything from before that. Discovering classic games like Chrono Trigger and experiencing them for the first time is nothing short of mind-blowing. I never played a Zelda game in my life, but I'm changing that with A Link to the Past.

With one free emulator, you can relive all of gaming's past glories. The SNES has aged particularly well, and classics like Earthbound are still pretty fun today. That right there sealed the deal for me in favor of phones. You can basically get the Nintendo DSi store on your phone. With that, why bother with a 3DS?

Comments
  • boo! I wholeheartedly disagree with you. Uncharted Golden Abyss will NEVER be on a phone. Gameloft can copy crap all they want, but it wont be the same. Plus, the Vita will have majority of the things you just cited. Phone? We've got video chat. Comic books and teh interwebz? Got that. Emulators? I'm playing OoT on my PSP. Netflix? It's on the PS3, why not the Vita? Not to mention the Android support (albeit we don't know much yet). The Vita is a great competitor to smart phones. And if Sony has "App" like things, plus it's horse power? Yeah buddy. I'm a little meh on the 3Ds though.
  • I disagree Apozem. I cant play Ocarina of Time or Uncharted on my Iphone, it won't happen. Your right practically speaking, the Iphone can do more, can multitask, etc. 3DS is going to get Netflix by the way in 3D, so that isn't valid. You can play old hardcore games, but what about new mario, zelda, star fox, luigi's mansion, etc. The 3DS and Vita have there own advantages that the Iphone doesn't have. Iphones are awesome, but that doesn't mean that handheld consoles don't have their place.
  • Compelling points, but portable versions of Uncharted and Little Big Planet that almost rival the graphical splendor of the console versions? Sold. Besides, I have yet to meet the phone control scheme that I don't hate. Until I see an analog stick and some buttons on that there intellergent talking machine, no thank you.

    BTW, have you ever read Ed Brubaker's Criminal? Great Crime Noir comic.
  • Yeah, I'm kind of with you on the controls. Touch screen analog sticks suck. But, on the other hand, native controls like in Cut the Rope are excellent. Thanks also for the comic recommendation. Noire comics are the best.

  • I'm sure this won't come as a shock to you but I disagree as well. I have had a droid for a year now and while I have enjoyed some very deep and rewarding games such as cut the rope, angry birds and plants vs zombies, they still in no way come close to what I will be able to get on a vita. I am worried about having to carry around anotheer device as well but for the most part I would only bring my vita on trips or just play it while I'm watching tv. Fruit ninja isn't nearly as fun as god of war. Nuff said.

  • Well, I'm still stuck with my old Sony Ericsson w200i, which today unfortunately got an even worse appearance than it had. We were, once again, playing stone throwing games, me and my few friends, over a very long distance. For a long time they could not hit me, but suddenly one of the bigger ones came so straight towards me that when I realized it, I could only save myself, but the stone did hit my mobile phone in the pocket. Current result is (when including previous damage): Display is not working, camera is not working, minor external and internal body damage. But I can listen to music, call to essential people and activate the alarm clock.

  • I see some of the merits of handheld consoles, but I definitely agree with this blog post. Smartphones are just better than handheld consoles. With my iPod touch I feel like I've got access to the whole world in my pocket. And it also helps that it's pretty small so I don't look and feel like I'm rocking a gigantic rectangular erection when I carry it in my pocket.

    Sure the Vita has Uncharted and LittleBigPlanet, but why on Earth would I want to pay $40-$50 to play gimped versions of amazing console games when I can play awesome $1-$10 downloadable games that actually feel like they were made specifically for mobile platforms? Also, I can buy 20-50 addictive downloadable games for the same amount of money as it would cost me to buy a single new game on a dedicated gaming handheld. Sure some of the more hardcore games need work on the controls and graphics, but I'm really not interested in paying $30 to $40 per game more just to be more comfortable and have a prettier game. And heck, ARM just recently said that their mobile phone chip will be producing 360- and PS3-quality graphics by 2013.

    Additionally, the multifaceted nature of smartphones blows away that of any handheld console. Netflix, Skype, HD movies, texting, phone calls, Facebook, Twitter, photos, HD tv shows, news, podcasts, music, using the phone as a router, and using the phone as a mouse are just some of the hundreds of functions that a decent smartphone can perform. I'll be shocked if the Sony Vita has even a tenth of the total number of functions of a smartphone.

    As you said at the beginning of the blog, it may be hard for some hardcore gamers to admit, but dedicated handhelds are a thing of the past. Even with Ocarina of Time 3D out, I still use my iPod Touch more than my 3DS, and I'll definitely be upgrading to the rumored iPhone 5 this fall rather than buying a Vita as originally planned. Hardcore gamers can disagree they want, but smartphones are definitely the future of mobile gaming.

    Great blog, Apozem.
  • I've gone this long without ever owning a handheld gaming unit, I can probably do without the Vita as well...

  • I disagree.
  • I disagree.

  • The best thing about the DSlite? The fact that I don't have to pay 30 bucks extra a month PER LINE to use it.

    On AT&T, it costs an extra (on top of the cost for the line and an extra 30 bucks for texting). I am not going to spend more than 60 bucks a month on a phone, much less over 120 dollars for both my husband and I.

    I have a Samsung phone with a camcorder/photo/text ability. I love using it to take pictures and movies, and I generally send stuff like grocery lists and stuff to my husband.

    But honestly, I'm kind of glad I can't access the internet from work-I'd never get any work done!

    I also prefer the keyboard set up on my laptop to communicating on the internet.

    Of course, I'm not all that sold on the 3DS or the Vita either. *sigh* I would much rather have something more in the flavor of a lightscreen that I can maximize and minimize into a small compact item that is drop resistant.

    Eh, that's what I would prefer to wait to have.

    EDIT: Also, I totally agree with everyone who was talking about how touchscreen controls suck when they expect you to use your fingers (*** you touch screen phones for not accepting stylus precision!).

    But my least favorite thing about "bar" shaped electronics is the "easily scratched screen" problem. Sure, you can put a screen protector on, but it still gets scratched to hell. My NDS lite (gold triforce edition) is still far less messy and scratched up than my phone or my PSP (and I'm VERY careful with my electronics too). I kind of think that one of the Playstation handhelds that folds looks super sexy.....
  • I'd hold off on signing contracts with Verizon; they're now owned by AT&T, and are being phased out... so unless they've some great contract you can get grandfathered in with that beats out what AT&T offers (they don't), you're just signing up for an inevitable headache when they switch over.

    Also never believe the hype when a provider says they're the only one with a given Android/HTC phone; LIES, they all have the same phones, they just change the branding for each carrier.
  • hey Apozem, what's the name of the SNES emulator
  • I see your point, but personally I've never been a huge fan of smart phone touchscreens; they always seem imprecise/hard-to-use, even for simpler actions like dialing a number or texting. If and when I do upgrade to a smartphone, I'll probably still have a seperate handheld console for most of my gaming. The SNES emulator does sound intriguing though.
  • This is a very good blog and I do wonder how handhelds are going to hold their own on the market nowadays.

  • I have to disagree

    isn't the Vita supposed to do Netflix? besides, you can use the PS Store to buy movies. Also, the concept that mobile games are better than, say, New Super Mario Bros, God of War GoS, or Patapon 2? Im sorry, but I will never submit to casual being better than hardcore

  • That's the problem- the casual platform has become hardcore. World of Goo, b*tches.