The lights are on
Veteran Member - Level 13
There's a good reason why Mario is the most recognizable face in the history of the gaming industry. His core titles have been, without exception, fantastic gaming experiences and pure platforming bliss. While the plumber has seen missteps in spin-off series like Mario Party, Mario Sports Mix, and his Olympic romps with former rival Sonic, the core series is as close to perfection as we've seen in a long-running franchise. With this blog, I'm inviting plenty of debate in the comments about how it should be ordered. Some gamers hate Super Mario Sunshine, others will passionately debate whether Super Mario Bros. 3 or World is better, and others will trash Super Mario Bros. 2 for not being a "real" entry. Regardless of what your personal choices may be, here are my picks for the ten best Mario titles of all time. I'm not weighing factors such as historical importance...these are ranked strictly on fun factor. Debate away.
10. Super Mario Bros. (NES, 1985)
With the introduction of series mainstays like the fire flower and mushroom, the iconic music and sound effects, and its challenging-yet-rewarding gameplay, the first Super Mario Bros. laid a foundation that still has an impact in 2011. Every Mario game ever owes its existence to the great platformer that Shigeru Miyamoto presented to gamers in 1985, and it still plays well today. It may not feature all the bells and whistles of later titles, but its rock-solid controls and level variety make it more than just a nostalgia act.
9. Super Mario Bros. 2 (NES, 1988)
Out of the ten games on this list, this is the only one that doesn't feature the traditional "jump on that thing's head to kill it" gameplay. The reasons for this dramatic departure are well known, but that doesn't make it stick out any less. By giving gamers access to four characters with wildly different play styles, relying on an odd vegetable-throwing mechanic, and omitting familiar enemies from the first Super Mario Bros., Nintendo certainly ran a risk with this sequel. This risk paid off, as Super Mario Bros. 2 proved to be a fantastic title that plays better than the legendary original.
8. New Super Mario Bros. (DS, 2006)
This DS title released over a decade after the last proper 2D entry, and it proved that Nintendo hadn't missed a beat. New power-ups like the Mega Mushroom and blue Koopa shell felt natural in this familiar environment, and the game controlled like second nature to longtime fans. Its 80 stages presented classic gameplay without relying on touchscreen gimmicks, making the game seem like a natural successor to the series' SNES entries. With nearly 20 million units sold, this return to form was an undeniable success. Lifelong Nintendo fans loved it, but (more importantly) it simultaneously introduced an entirely new generation to the joys of 2D Mario.
Read on to see where Mario's 3D debut ranks among his best games.
Email the author Dan Ryckert, or follow on Twitter, Google+, Facebook, and Game Informer.
Mario is one of the few series in history that needs no drastic changes to the formula, that can hit it out of the park on the same charms it always has. That makes it really hard to rank each one, but the only thing I would question here is the high placement of the Galaxy series.
Good list, though I'd put New Super Mario Bros. higher.
Awesome write up! Had a great time reading it and you put your list together well. and i agree on your number 1 for sure.
I agree with all of your choices except for putting Super Mario Galaxy 1 and 2 so high on the list. I mean they were fun games but SMG 2 basically took what SMG did and made it slightly better.
Great list. I like how World and SMB 3 ended up. My personal favorite is Super Mario RPG for the SNES, but I understand only doing the core series.
Is it just me, our does anyone else not count Super Mario World 2: Yoshi's Island as a core Mario game. Don't get me wrong its an amazing game, but I count it as a Yoshi game not a Mario one.
I'll always prefer the first Mario Bros. Aminly because it was my first game.
Great list, Dan!
I feel like Super Mario Bros. 3 should be one of the best video games in the world.
Good List but some people are going to complain that Galaxy should have been higher.
I really like the list but I think SMB3 should be number one. Also, I think I would have left sunshine out and added the Japan only SMB2 (the lost levels or whatever they call it on VC).
So glad you put World over SMB3. World is 2D platforming perfection, just like Donkey Kong Country was on the SNES and Donkey Kong Country Returns was for the Wii.
Super Mario World is my favorite too.
Nice galaxy and sunshine made it.