The lights are on
After seeing a CNN report in which anchor Erin Burnett tried to badger psychologist and author William Pollack into saying that there was a hard link between games and recent violent shooting sprees, the Twisted Metal creator wrote a rant directed at the network.
You can watch the original CNN clip below. The video game segment starts at 2:58. While Pollack seems concerns about game violence, he flatly answers "No" when asked if games caused the recent tragedies that have occurred, and quickly moved the conversation to the easy availability of weapons in the U.S. Burnett seems unswayed by his opinions and tries time and again to bring the blame back to games.
Jaffe didn't take kindly to this, and offered this statement vie his Twitlonger account:
Dear @ErinBurnett : you, ma'am, are at best an idiot that @cnn should be ashamed to have as an anchor. At worst, you are the worst kind of American: one who has allowed the healthy desire for success to morph into a capitalistic cancer that makes it ok to ignore the facts in order to make your product more appealing, regardless of the consequences. To make matters worse, your own views about video games- which you seem to have no problem sharing with your hundreds of thousands of viewers- clearly have not been formed by any actual research or real life experience with the medium.
I am sure you will think yourself quick and insightful when you tell me- a video game director/designer accusing someone from another industry of making products for profit regardless of consequence- that I am the pot and you are the black kettle. However, if you actually listened to your guests and read the studies (aka if you actually did some....some....hmmm, what's that word you journalists have for it? Oh right: RESEARCH!) you would see you are wrong; you would see there remains- after years of studies- zero evidence of video games with violent subject matter causing real life violence.
On the flip side- you know: YOUR side- there is very real evidence that our society suffers greatly when our news media fails to properly inform the public.
The fact that you think a guy who 'trains'* on a shooting video game would be granted the skill to horrifically, tragically kill those CHILDREN in Norway only serves to show how little research you do before you open your mouth in front of your world wide audience under the guise of delivering news. I'm not sure what makes your argument look more ignorant: the fact that you don't back up your idiotic statement by showing a correlation to the current health of America's agriculture sector with the popularity of Farmville OR the fact that the sick, deranged evil loser who killed those poor kids in Norway had picked such a poor 'training' tool that after 700 hours of play, he was only capable of hitting little kids with his bullets versus the well armed pretend terrorists and highly skilled virtual soldiers that he was battling in the game.
Shame on you. But more importantly: shame on your profession. It deserves so much better.**
Source: The Escapist
Email the author Matt Helgeson, or follow on Twitter, and Game Informer.
That was.....satisfying to read. Bravo.
The video gave me a migraine and possibly an aneurysm with its amount of stupid. Can I hold CNN, or the host accountable for this?
It kills me how she kept going back to Video Games. The guy flat out says NO on mutliple occassions but she wasn't satisfied with it, and tried to bring up other things like the Norway killer who did that because he hated a certain belief not because he played games. I mean yes he said he "trained" using games but he mostly played WoW, how is that training to shoot kids? At least the video game industry has the ratings system in place that does NOT allow kids to purchase games that are deemed inappropriate. The whole games cause people to shoot people thing is irrelevent, and always will be.
Is anyone going to listen to Jaffe?
I hate that we still need to have this discussion. That anyone can think playing games or listening to music ever caused psychosis...
Just the other day I was hoping Jaffe would throw his two cents into this debate. Thank you for never disappointing.
Heh. Well I'm glad someone with stature finally said what every one of us has wanted to for years. The condescending 'how bout you do your job' tone just makes it perfect. Well done.
This is great. Take that, news! I just wish these idiots would take the time to listen to people like David Jaffe and Adam Sessler.
This discussion is old and a waste. Thank you David for speaking up.
thanks dave, good job!!!!!!
While I totally agree with Jaffe, I'm not sure how I feel about him representing us; these reporters would go to town with Twisted Metal.
I'm both surprised and impressed by the lack of profanity in his letter.