Switch Lights

The lights are on

What's Happening

Politicians, Media Continue To Tie Video Games To Newtown Tragedy

In the wake of the tragic mass shooting at Sandy Hook Elementary in Newtown, Connecticut, members of the news media and politicians are turning their eye to the role that violent video games might have played in the shootings. 

The most prominent move came from U.S. Senator Jay Rockefeller, who has introduced legislation that would task the National Academy of Sciences to conduct a study to determine whether or not violent video games causes aggressive or violent behavior in children. Of course, the fact that literally dozens of studies have been conducted on the same topic -- and found no hard link between video games and real-life violent behavior -- isn't dissuading Rockefeller.

David Axelrod, one of President Obama's senior advisors, also got in on the action with his personal Twitter account, tweeting: "In NFL post-game: an ad for shoot 'em up video game. All for curbing weapons of war. But shouldn't we also quit marketing murder as a game?"

The game industry has been measured in its response to the criticism, perhaps not wanting to seem callous to the real pain and suffering so many families in Newtown are experiencing.

Here is an official statement from the Entertainment Software Association, the main industry trade organization in video games:

“The Entertainment Software Association, and the entire industry it represents, mourns the tragedy at Sandy Hook Elementary School. The search for meaningful solutions must consider the broad range of actual factors that may have contributed to this tragedy. Any such study needs to include the years of extensive research that has shown no connection between entertainment and real-life violence.”

Daniel Greenberg, the chairman of the Independent Game Developers Association, went on Fox News to speak with anchor Neil Cavuto about the alleged ties between the Newtown massacre and violent games. As you can see in the clip below, Greenberg found Cavuto to be somewhat hostile to his viewpoints, and found himself dismissively cut off at the end of the segment.

While it's certain that Newtown shooter Adam Lanza played video games, reports regarding what types of games he enjoyed have varied. Some sources hold that he played violent games like Call of Duty and Starcraft, while others that knew him said he was an adept player of Konami's popular arcade game Dance Dance Revolution (one of the least violent games on the market). Of course, the likely reality is that, like most young men of his age, he had a wide range of gaming tastes. Still, as Lanza left few clues as to why he conducted the sickening attack, his motives and the influences on his behavior will likely always be a guessing game.

In the weeks to come, expect video games to come under increasing scrutiny. However, the landmark 2011 decision by the Supreme Court on the case of Brown vs. EMA did establish that the court considers video games protected speech under the First Amendment of the Constitution, which would make it difficult for politicians to outright censor violent games.

Sources: Bloomberg, GamePolitics, Politico, NBC News

Email the author , or follow on , and .

Comments
  • They're absolutely correct. I remember back in the days of the steam engine, people were killing eachother on the streets in such non gentlemanly ways, inspired by 1-bit shoot 'em ups.
  • You know what game should be banned? The Blame Game. It's the game lots of people love to play after there's been a tragedy. We don't need a study to tell us that games don't make people violent. I'm sick of these morons.
  • Way to cut him off you ***. He refutes him completely and is opening for a constructive conversation and is blown off.
  • THis is why I hate the *** media these days.
  • Isn't the media supposed to encourage Democracy?

    The media did the same thing to Ron paul, it was kind of sad.
  • Fox News............we meet again. *squints eyes to look tough*
  • I have a better idea on how congressmen can spend their time. Why don't they work on approving the budget or fix government spending. I'm glad to hear that a Senator from W. Virginia has the free time to focus on proposing a bill that focuses on the research of violent video games considering W. Virginia is currently facing a debt of $5 Billion.
  • They are really just spitting in our faces now. The fact that they can't even google search 'video games and violence' they need to conduct a survey that will probably be the deciding factor on how they proceeded. This is just a repeat performance of SOPA where the legislators have no knowledge about how the internet of video games work besides their own narrow point of view on the subject. But the worst thing about this is that this is just a scapegoat for much more concerning matters *cough* *cough* Guns/ Mental health *cough* or they actually believe what they are doing is the right thing to do.
  • I guess we should ban violent games now. In fact, while we're at it let's just ban violent TV, or books that don't come across as kid friendly. Actually, no more second amendment. That would be a welcome change, now wouldn't it?
  • Mr Greenberg did a great job articulating his responses to Cavuto's inquiries. I did not see the entire segment (unless this is the whole segment posted here), so I would hope he was able to draw comparisons to how film and pop music and heavy metal have been villainized in a similar manner in the past. It seems like video games are the new whipping post.

  • Blame movies... they're much more realistic when it comes to this kind of event. The movie "Zero Day" was a mocumentary of two high schoolers planning a school shooting, has there been a game about it? No. Every anchor on Fox News are one-sided ignorant slobs.
  • Okay. Sure. Let's blame video games. Not the mental state. Alright.
  • As every generation dies off and another raises to take it's place something is found to be the reason those younger than them behave in such 'strange' or different ways.  Blaming games for violence is like blaming rock and roll for sex and movies for drug use. People make choices and they're not always good.  Stand up for personal accountability and stop coming up with ways to pass the buck America!

  • That mother****** is an ***. My stuff is real yours isn't. Call of Duty grosses more money than blockbuster movie events and black ops 2 actually beats the record for any blockbuster movie event.
  • That is a load. A HUGE Load. Many people play video games, and if they say that video games influence how people act, then, by jove, I'd be walking around with a sword made out of diamonds swinging it at everything dressed in green, skeleton clothing, or zombie clothing. So yea.
  • If video games were the cause of this aggression, wouldn't there be much more violence given how many copies of shooters get sold? Also, consider the mental state of the people who do these things. I don't get why these people are so quick to blame something they know absolutely nothing about other than they know absolutely nothing about it, which is an asinine thing to do in the first place.
  • I have BPD, depression and numerous other issues, I've been playing videogames since I was 5.. I'm 21 now never went on a murderous spree. They need to not be pushing this and focus on the real issues. I feel really bad for the families
  • What is this nonsense?!? VIDEO GAMES INFLUENCE VIOLENCE?!?!? What RUBBISH! I kill people in videogames.  That doesn't make me A PSYCHOTIC SERIAL KILLER WITH MURDEROUS INTENTIONS. Why don't you focus on more pressing matters than trivialities like videogame violence?

  • I *love* how the media has said the killers name about 12 times an hour since the event, and completely shuts down any discussion about how those invocations might have something to do with the accelerating/copycat/one-upping nature of these crimes. The news/newstainment industry needs to stop turning killers into media super villains all the while pointing the finger at every other aspect of culture/media.
  • It sickens me to see politicians and the media always trying to make the gaming industry as the scapegoat. For example, Fox News reported that Adam Lanza liked Mass Effect, despite the fact that he didnt even have a Facebook account, and it was actually his brother who liked the game. Yet it didn't stop their stupid demographic from attacking Bioware.

    Gaming is not the issue here. *** the media and these *** politicians.
1 2 3 4 5 Next ... Last