Switch Lights

The lights are on

What's Happening

Reader Discussion: Star Trek Or Star Wars?

One group's ambitious quest to build a full-scale Millennium Falcon has Star Wars on our minds. Nerds love arguing for the things we love. Few nerdy fires rage as brightly as the debate over Star Trek or Star Wars being the superior science-fiction series. So out with it, already: Rancors or Romulans? Kirk or Luke? The Force or beamin' up?

Let me start. My first true introduction to sci-fi involved seeing Star Wars Episode IV: A New Hope when the special editions hit theaters. The easy-to-follow story, lightsaber fights, and bad-ass Han Solo were enough to hook me on the space opera. I patiently waited for the other two films in the original trilogy to release, and instantly fell in love with Boba Fett, speeder bikes, and the Battle of Hoth. Layer on a generous helping of Star Wars merchandise and games like Dark Forces to play with, and my fandom was sealed.

Around that time I would also catch episodes of the original Star Trek TV show. I didn’t have the perspective I have now, so I didn’t appreciate how seminal the series was to all science fiction. The cheesy acting, fake-looking monsters, and slowly paced episodes couldn’t keep my attention. Also, the terrible Star Trek games never could stack up against the Super Star Wars series, further solidifying my opinion. Since then I’ve attempted to get into the Star Trek series, but it never sticks. 

I confidently call myself a Star Wars guy, by a huge margin. I respect Star Trek and hope to experience the series' entire, massive offering, but I'd rather rewatch the original Star Wars trilogy any day.

Make your case for either, or both, in the comments below.

Email the author , or follow on , and .

Comments
  • Definitely Star Wars.
  • SPACEBALLS!
  • What's the difference?
  • I don't like this question because I do actually like both. If push came to shove though, I have to go with Star Trek, specifically TNG. The characters and writing of the tv shows were of much higher quality than anything in star wars. That being said, the Star Trek TNG movies are horrible and don't hold a candle to the original Star Wars trilogy.
  • Star Wars!

  • Star Wars!!!!! Jedi Knights kick ass!

  • Doctor Who? Well, I've only seen a few episodes of Star Trek, so Star Wars.
  • Star Wars.

    I don't get the Space Elves... sorry.
  • I feel a great disturbance on the Internet, as if millions of fanboys suddenly cried out in argument, only to be flamed. I feel something terrible has happened...
  • Realism and depth goes to Star Trek. Creativity goes to Star Wars.
  • I love both too much, but if I HAD to pick one, it would be Star Wars, even with the prequel BS.
  • I think Star Wars is much more entertaining, with much more action and pretty effects on the side, and it has awesome cannon. I know more and have followed Star Wars for quite some time, so I'd say I'm a Star Wars fan.

    On the flip side, I respect Star Trek a ton: it questions the ethics and morals of a space-faring race, of what's humane and what's not. I think Star Trek leads the viewer into tough moral decisions. It's kinda like Mass Effect in that way: both spend a ton of time talking to people and making decisions, with action spaced in between. But the writing and characters are so good, the conversations more than pull their own weight.
  • I don't need to make a case, Star Wars is clearly better.

  • Star Wars for me. Was really my first Sci-Fi anything.

  • I grew up watching a lot of Star Wars so I can relate to it better. I watched Star Trek Next Generation movies and they were good from what I remember, the last one was fantastic. If the story is interesting then either one is fine. BTW, I didn't realize Darth Maul came back until I saw him with mechanical legs on a youtube video...and then there is his brother, Savage...I think I've seen enough Star Wars for quite awhile :P

  • If you had asked me before the 09 Star Trek reboot, I would have said Star Wars. I'm super exited to see the new Star Trek sequel.
  • Star Wars is soooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo much better.

  • i would say im a huge fan of both, but for different reasons.  when you put both series side-by-side, they're really too different to compare.  both have strengths, both have weaknesses.  i've been a fan of both since birth and love star wars and star trek equally.  the whole argument over which is better just doesn't make sense to me cuz when it comes down to it, they're apples and oranges

  • You might say Star Wars is cooler, but Star Trek is philosophical, interesting and way ahead of its time. I haven't seen the movie trilogy yet. I actually have the first movie saved on my dvr right now, but the original series is...fascinating. Compared to Star Trek, Star Wars is a bunch of kids running around playing space man. Star Trek's jokes and style are the definition of camp at this point, though. That could be a good thing or a bad thing depending on how you look at it.
  • I like both. But after watching the Star Trek movie that came out a few years ago, I'm more interested in Star Trek.

1 2 3 4 5 Next ... Last