Switch Lights

The lights are on

Gabe Newell: Windows 8 Is A "Catastrophe"

Valve's Gabe Newell has announced his displeasure with the upcoming Windows 8, because he believes it will lead to a more closed platform.

Speaking to Ed Fries at the Casual Connect conference in Seattle, Newell expressed his opinion when talking about having options when it comes to different platforms (including the company's expansion into Linux) and the openness of those platforms. Newell believes that Windows 8 in particular will make the PC more of a closed system. "I think that Windows 8 is kind of a catastrophe for everybody in the PC space," said Newell. "I think that we’re going to lose some of the top-tier PC [original equipment manufacturers]. They’ll exit the market. I think margins are going to be destroyed for a bunch of people."

Although Newell doesn't go into specifics of what he finds so offensive, Microsoft is putting more strict hardware requirements on machines that are licensed to run Windows 8, and the tablet version (Windows RT) exclusively runs software purchased through Microsoft's app store. These requirements could make it harder for companies like Dell who rely on lower-end hardware. Also, Newell's Steam store front will be locked out of Windows RT, similarly to how everything for Apple's iOS has to go through that company.

Windows 8 comes out on October 26.

For more of Newell's comments at the conference, head over to Venture Beat.

Email the author , or follow on , and .

Comments
  • it looks soo simple that theres going to be nothing customizable :( i like my vista.

  • Once upon a time companies would watch the market, find a need and them create a product to fill that need. It seems now there is a tendency to just put something out and tell everyone that they want it. I'll be sticking with Win 7 until this whole thing blows over.
  • I have to work on a mac all day and it sucks. Everything is limited and slow and completely backwards. I'm in no way new to macs, been working on them for about ten years now. But when I go home and sit at my pc with 24 gigs of ram, duel GTX 590 video cards, i9 processor and liquid cooling, I always think to myself why on earth anyone ever puts money into apple products. But this... windows 8 has scared me from the get go. It's way to simplistic and looks absolutely annoying. DO NOT take apple's que and start limiting what the customer can and cannot do.
  • I have to work on a mac all day and it sucks. Everything is limited and slow and completely backwards. I'm in now way new to macs, been working on them for about ten years now. But when I go home and sit at my pc with 24 gigs of ram, duel GTX 590 video cards, i9 processor and liquid cooling, I always think to myself why on earth anyone ever puts money into apple products. But this... windows 8 has scared me from the get go. It's way to simplistic and looks absolutely annoying. DO NOT take apple's que and start limiting what the customer can and cannot do.
  • I have Windows 8 and Steam, they work fine together, I don't see the problem...

  • I'm mainly a console game (aside from the occasional game from Steam), so can someone tell me what the big fuss is?
  • Maybe Microsoft is just tired of Windows' reputation being tarnished by poor hardware quality. I don't blame them for wanting their OS to shine on better hardware. But it does come with a price.

    It may actually push manufacturers to release better quality products, rather than pushing them out of the market. It may force down the cost of hardware. Who doesn't like that?
  • I agree with Gabe. I am going to stick with Windows 7 for as long as I can.

  • I'm not a fan at all of 8. Hopefully this is another windows version that crashes and burns fast enough thats its replaced before I get a new computer.

    Why does everyone think these tablets are the way to go? Sure they're better than nothing when you're out and about. But they're crap compared to my pc.
  • With this news, I'm sooooooo glad to be on Ubuntu (Linux). F**k Microsoft!
  • This will be in the bargain bin next to unsold copies of Windows "ME" and Windows Vista if this is the case.

  • looks kinda dumb :P

  • So glad I'm not the only one that thinks this. Microsoft has truly gone insane with this. I downloaded the beta a few months back and tried to stick with it, but it's exactly what Gabe was saying about creating a more closed off platform. Scrapping everything everyone has gotten used to since the UI was created is not making things more accessible by any stretch of the imagination. I'm not saying they shouldn't try new things and try to improve upon stuff, but why try to forget all these years of evolution; improve upon that! This new UI just does not work well with conventional computers and I'm starting to doubt it's any better for actual touch based devices. There really needs to be a distinction between the two; give conventional pc users an OS they're familiar with and new touch based technology completely its own thing. Is that crazy thinking, am I the irrational one here? Sounds like what they should have done. I'm anticipating another boycott as bad as Vista if touch based computing doesn't skyrocket soon.
  • Is it just me, or is every other release of Windows destined for failure? But, I'm not sweating it. I've been warming up to Linux for awhile now. And now that Steam has announced that it will try to support Linux... yeah.
  • It's funny to see him complaining, yet doing nothing about it. Rather than being a lazy developer and complain, get your butt into gear and make it work! I have Windows 8 Release Preview and it didn't bother me at all in any way.
  • im happy with Windows 7 x64 .. there is no reason at all,for me to buy Windows 8... and srsly.. who in their right mind would Buy Windows 8 when Windows 7 is only 3 years old? If you got Windows 7,its just monney out the window,if you buy Windows 8. No Puns intended.
  • I doubt I'll be experience Windows 8, considering I finally bought a new PC in November after having waited since 2005.

  • I'll just with windows 7 in the mean time

  • It seems Microsoft are trying to do what Apple did, but are failing badly at it.

    Apple, most of their devices look the same and are simliar layouts. They make it work though because theres a few differences and all.

    Microsoft have thought about doing this too making it simple. They haven't nailed it though. It just looks the same on xbox, phones and now their computers, and most likely Surface.

    People go to Apple a lot because they look the same and feel the same but you can tell the difference and you dont get bored with it, but with Microsoft, it all just looks the same and you would probably get sick of the layout being on everything.

  • Just buy a Mac!