Switch Lights

The lights are on

What's Happening

Reader Discussion: Does The Kinect Still Matter? Did It Ever Matter?



The Kinect is an amazing piece of technology. It responds to your voice and body movements, and it helps blind people see (sort of).  When it comes to playing games though, the very thing it was designed to do, has anything really blown you away? Has anything you’ve seen made you run out and buy the device? Will the Kinect have longevity as a video game peripheral? Or is it destined for the pile of plastic guitars and drums sitting in your closet next to that thing you bought just to have that random Zelda shooting game?



When the Kinect was first being shown with Dance Central, it was a must buy in my household. My wife was very excited, but I wasn’t sure how much fun I would be able to derive from a device that required full-body movement, something I specifically use video games to avoid. I ended up a convert though, and had a lot of fun with Dance Central and its sequel. The Gunstringer offered some fleeting fun and used the Kinect well, and Fruit Ninja was worth a few wild gesticulations in the name of chopping fruit, but is there anything else? Are you excited about how Kinect is being implemented in titles like Mass Effect 3 and the upcoming Ghost Recon? Or do those just represent additional features that you won’t take advantage of?

Sound off below, and tell us: does the Kinect matter?

Email the author , or follow on , , , and .

Comments
  • Waiting for Mass Effect 3 and Ghost Recon.
  • kinects fun for 5 min
  • I think its fun.
  • No,I was never interested in it.
  • I mean, there's really no games out like in the original promo. I think the only game hype it had was that canceled Milo project. I would have played that.
  • . stupid voice commands and flailing at the screen to fire my weapon dont impress me at all even if they work perfectly.the technology isnt where it needs to be for true controller free gaming. check back in 10 years. till then gimme that controller.
  • If Bioware can't pull it off, no one can. That is all.
  • It mattered for about 5 minutes, but then again, that's 5 more minutes than the Move, so I guess that's a win for Microsoft?
  • Not really to both questions

  • Right now, I think it's fun for those small games like fruit ninja. Oh, and Dance Central, although i've never played it, im sure the kinect is super important for delivering a very fun experience. As of right now however, it hasn't really played a huge part in some of the very big popular games. Hopefully in the future, it'll be more involved with awesome games in the future.

  • I think the technology matters. I've seen modders do some amazing things with the Kinect and there's a ton of potential to really give gamers something new. In its current state, it's not much more than a novelty.
  • No, nothing has really blown me away about it. I'm looking forward to ryse (spelling?). I was going to get rise of nightmares but the poor reviews scared me away. As of now it seems to be getting a lot of shovelware. I hope some developers really take the peripheral seriously and figure out how to take full advantage of this great technology.
  • kinect is the most boring and terrible thing i have ever seen and used on a friend house,games are boring only a few are good,it get you tired fast,and it have a lot of game to loss weigth...but im not FAT!
  • Sorry, you need to update the article. Bioware already announced that they are removing Kinect from Mass Effect 3. That's a win for the non-kinect folk like myself. There's not a game out that makes me want to go out and buy Kinect.
  • It never mattered.

  • Its a nice gimmick, but in practice I must say no

  • I don't see the point in ever picking it up, especially at it's current price.
  • It is an amazing piece of technology, but the games were a huge let-down.  Still, I can't wait to see what the PC community does with it.  

  • It's just another gimmick to me. I feel like they just made it so Microsoft can try to hide the fact that the Xbox was meant to be a game console.
  • The only good thing kinect had was the marketing, the real thing did not mattered.

1 2 3 4 5 Next ... Last