Switch Lights

The lights are on

UPDATE: Industry Experts Respond To Nintendo HD News

UPDATE: A few more reactions rolled in over the weekend. Check the second page of this story to read them.

ORIGINAL STORY: Yesterday GI broke the news from multiple trusted sources that Nintendo will reveal a new HD-capable console by or at E3 of this year. While new rumors about the system have continued popping up around the web, we decided to gather some early thoughts about the timing and necessity of this announcement from various industry experts.

Shane Bettenhausen, Director of Business Development, Ignition Entertainment:

"I’m eager for this thing to be revealed! In my estimation, Nintendo actually needs to announce some details on its next home console at this year’s E3 in order to remain competitive in the home console race. As exciting as the Wii was a few years back, it’s truly showing its age and has become increasingly difficult for third parties to find success on the platform of late. The challenge that Nintendo faces is to make a console that has more to offer than just the valuable ‘Nintendo DNA’ and the incredible first-party support that we’ve come to expect. And gimmickry won’t be enough to make this a clear leader…I’m hoping that its specs and capabilities will really surprise everyone."

Denis Dyack, President, Silicon Knights:

"If this is true, I am very excited! With the Wii Nintendo showed innovation that resulted in growth for the industry, so I cannot wait to see what they have planned next. Of course, a new Nintendo console will also result in the next round of Nintendo games, which I look forward to playing on day one.”

Michael Pachter, Managing Director, Wedbush Securities:

"I have no [previous] knowledge at all, as I get all of my news from Game Informer. With that said, I think that the right time for a launch was in front of the launches of Kinect and Move, and think that Nintendo missed the ‘perfect’ time to launch in 2009. They could have launched at $300, and would have been competitive with Kinect and Move bundles and may have kept Wii households from upgrading to one of the other consoles. In my view, every Kinect and Move bundle sold cost Nintendo the opportunity to convert or retain a customer, so 2009 was the right time to launch. Once they passed on a 2009 launch, they should have pushed to get the Wii 2 out at the same time as Kinect and Move (late 2010), to at least compete for the market share captured by Microsoft and Sony. Once again, they chose to wait, and recent hardware figures show that they missed an opportunity. I think that there is still significant interest in a Wii 2, particularly from the very large Wii installed base, so it is not ‘too late,’ but it’s also not the ‘right time.'"

Lee Jacobson, Senior Vice President of Licensing and Digital Publishing, Atari:

"Nintendo has always marched to the beat of their own drum and never engaged in the same graphical arms race that defined the Xbox 360 and PS3. I for one am excited to see what their next move is at E3, as Atari has always done very well on Nintendo systems and we know that whatever they announce will be high-quality and speak to an audience that is uniquely suited for their system."

John Davison, Vice President of Programming, CBS Interactive/GameSpot:

"It's been clear that something has been brewing at Nintendo for a while, and the timing is absolutely right for them to be making some bold steps with a successor to the Wii. Although very successful for the past few years, they've been incredibly late to a number of parties, and there's a huge opportunity for them to embrace the changes that the audience now expects from a modern game experience. Beyond motion controls or HD graphics, which are a given, there's a lot they could do in terms of digital distribution, cross-device connectivity, and social integration to prove they really ‘get it.’ Do I think they'll actually do this? Maybe. Judging from the 3DS it's clear they're not completely ready to embrace all of the current trends, but they seem to be taking baby steps in the right direction."

Comments
  • we might all have to eat our words on this. I believe Patcher (omfg. of all people.......) predicted this not too long ago. sorry dude....
  • All of this speculation is driving me insane! I want to see this beast, and get some confirmed games/specs. Of course this won't happen for a while, though.
  • One guy says 2009 was the right time, the other says 2012 is early...

    I wonder which (whichever isn't Pachter, haha - I couldn't imagine splurging on another new console that early). And what this thing is.
  • I wonder how much it will cost?
  • My hope is only that it will support a plethora of fun new and exciting games for me to enjoy while I seep into my couch for days on end.
  • Looking forward to it

  • Nintendo has always came out with interesting consoles and such and I'm excited to hear what else they have coming out.

  • Don't care. Its too little, too late. Maybe in 5 years when they drop in price, i'll pick one up to play Zelda.
  • Sick!!!

  • If nmh3 is a launch title, than I can say for sure that nintendo has sold a system.

  • My prediction is more of the same. It will be better than the Wii, but still not as good as the 360 or PS3. I for one am not excited. Personally I think Nintendo is good for one thing and one thing only and that's handhelds. I'll go one step further and say they should have done what Sega did and have just gotten out of the Console market and focused on game development... Imagine how many copies of Zelda, and Mario would have sold if they followed that path.
  • Pachter's right, unless Nintendo, once again, changes the game. They might. 3DS is pretty cool.

  • i hope they bring it this year at E3

  • Honestly, I'm tired of commenting on my continually growing excitement about this console, so instead I'm going to give it my own name. The "Nintendo Super High-Definition Console of Wonder" or NSHDCoW.
  • I can't wait to see waht Nintendo has in store for us.

  • Really Pachter? Really? I for one am extremely excited. I wonder if they'll give Capt. Falcon his game on this one. One can only hope....
  • Oh jeez

  • i totally agree with pachter.

  • I *** hate Micheal Patcher. "2009 was the right time to launch" my ass. I had bought a Wii in late 2008 and never regret it. Heck, late 2009 through all of 2010 was The Wii and its best. Am I excited for the Wii 2...Yes. I still hope it keeps motion controls. If the whole touchscreen is true that would be awesome. I look for change when I'm gaming, so if they stop being innovating and just stick with HD and graphics like Sony and Microsoft has been doing (not that i'm dissing the two companies) I would not just be upset by Nintendo, but ashamed as a gamer. I will however agree with Andy McNamara.
  • With all the stuff Im hearing about this, it sounds like this game wont be anything to sneeze on, and judging by how great the 3DS is, I wont sleep on it! I did that with the 3DS and almost didn't get mine so Im not messing around! But I also am kinda scared to see the price tag on this thing because stuff like screens in the controller don't come cheep! But I have to give credit where credit is due, and im sure Nintendo will be 12 steps ahead of the other guy as they usually are!
1 2 3 4 Next