Switch Lights

The lights are on

What's Happening

Ubisoft Obtains Injunction Against THQ

Stinging from the exodus of Assassin's Creed creator Patrice Désilets and at least three other key employees to the newly formed THQ Montreal studio, Ubisoft has obtained an injunction that prevents Désilets' new company from recruiting additional developers from his former employer.

French website Rue Frontenac broke the story, which Ubisoft confirmed to us with this official statement:

Ubisoft has filed a request before the Superior Court of Québec for injunction orders against THQ Inc. in order to have them comply with the non-solicit clause included in Ubisoft Montreal’s employee work contracts. The Superior Court of Québec has granted the injunctions to the satisfaction of Ubisoft. This procedure aims to protect Ubisoft Montreal in a breach of contract situation, and to defend the long-term financial and creative health of the studio.

The talent flight began last May, when Patrice Désilets abruptly walked away from the company for undisclosed reasons. Rue Frontenac reports that Désilets was making a considerable salary at the time of his departure, having earned $1.3 million Canadian dollars over the last three years of his employment with Ubisoft. In resigning his position, he also left up to $600,000 in future bonuses on the table.

The following July, THQ announced its intentions to form a new studio in Montreal. After months of speculation that Désilets was taking the lead position at the new studio, in October THQ officially announced that he is taking control after his Ubisoft non-compete clause expires in May.

During the same time period, Assassin's Creed artistic director Alex Drouin, production manager Mark Besner, and associate producer Jean-Francois Boivin all unexpectedly resigned from Ubisoft, citing various reasons like the wish to spend more time with family. The three departures piqued Ubisoft's interest considering that all three held Montreal Canadians season tickets with Désilets.

Ubisoft's suspicions proved valid in January when THQ exec Danny Bilson told Joystiq that it had hired the three Ubisoft employees at the behest of Désilets."I don't think I can talk about the other three people we've already contracted because I wouldn't … I just know Patrice said, 'I need these three guys.' And I said 'Okay! Whatever you need!'" he said. "We put all of them on retention and got them started on their non-compete [clauses]. I kind of know what their roles are, but they were the most important people to Patrice. All three of them are Ubi."

In mentioning Désilets' involvement in the recruitment of these employees, Bilson essentially admitted that his new studio head was in breach of contract, as his non-compete clause prevented Désilets' from recruiting employees for one year after his departure. Ubisoft presented the case to Judge Marc de Wever, who issued an injunction against THQ and Patrice Désilets on January 26.

Despite the injunction, THQ's overtures to Ubisoft employees persisted. Less than a month later, Ubisoft discovered that another employee, Margherita Seconnino, was approached by former employee Adolfo Gomez-Urda to meet with the THQ localization department, offering a salary raise upwards of 60 percent.

Upon reviewing this information, the court awarded Ubisoft this latest injunction, which adds Gomez-Urda to the injunction along with Désilets and THQ.

Email the author , or follow on , , , and .

Comments
  • I wonder if this will somehow mess up the creative intentions of the next Assassins creed.
  • To run away from $600,000 in bonuses he must have had a mighty fine offer on the table. I don't see how the other employees thought they could get away with it. I don't like liars!

  • "But you have $600,000 in bonuses. Why would you want to leave?"

    "Uh, I love mah family!"

  • ... then THQ proceeded to turn to Ubisoft and say, "U mad, bro?"
  • I'm happy for Desilets and THQ but I'm really worried for the Assassin's Creed franchise. It's lost too many key developers and I'm afraid that future titles won't hold up to the outstanding predecessors.
  • If you're going to leave a company, then just do so. Don't screw with their ability to do business. Considering the public nature of all this, it makes you and your new employer look bad.
  • Mod
    activision/infinity ward who? does ubisoft even have a treyarch waiting in its wings? will be interesting if not unsettling to see to what degree this impacts another popular franchise.
  • Those dang non compete clauses. As far as I know no one in the industry obeys them. They seem to serve the purpose only to allow the company that is shafted to sue or in this case file an injunction.
  • just pray that assassins creed franchise will still turn out perfect

  • this is going to kill one of my favorite gaming series D:
  • No, you can't get take that 60% higher paying job! What has the world come to?
  • Oh Ubisoft, it's not the dev talents fault that THQ is better than you
  • I can't remember the last time I bought a game published by THQ. Maybe with this new Dev. team and hopefully some original IP's, I can change all that. :)

  • Woooow, this dirty scoundrels. I mean, Im not especially a bug fan of Ubisoft (and their borthersome DRM), but that was just low. Spending more time with family? Jeez come on! Well, Im glad Ubisoft did what they had to. Now if they need some ideas for Assassins Creed 3, now I could definitely help with that... ;)

    Edit: I didnt realize how *** similar this is to the whole Activision-Infinity Ward thing. Its even right before the third game as well! So glad they plugged that whole before it sunk the boat. Mallat: "All right shows over people, NOW GET BACK TO WORK ON ASSASSINS CREED 3 BLAARGHAJFUABOF!"
  • good i knew assassins creed was fuged when they staryed pulling a activision ans pumping em out every year or 2

  • Cmon Desilets! Walk away from a very succesful franchise adn company to make your own projects by stealing the other three main people who designed AC franchise and made it good and go to Desilet for "family reasons"? How lame and low can you get. I thought you were above this Desilets. Shame on you just shame on you...>:(

  • Woah. That's some seriously heavy stuff. Congrats to Ubisoft for taking the initiative to stop that kind of crap - it really seems like borderline corporate(I'm not sure if that's the right word here, so if it's not, I apologize. I'm a tad scatterbrained because I may or may not be dealing with some preposterous jet lag right now...) espionage. It's a shame that the gaming industry has to deal with this sort of thing.

  • THQ is better than Ubisoft?

    That's hilarious.  

    And I wonder what sort of penalties can come from this sort of thing.  

  • I hope this doesn't mean bad things for AC. All those games kick ass.

  • Ubisoft has talent?
1 2 Next