Switch Lights

The lights are on

Ophthalmologist Recommends Long-Term Trials On 3DS' Safety

Nintendo's 3DS has already garnered a ton of attention, thanks to its impressive 3D capabilities. Those very capabilities are also raising concerns from some in the medical community. The vice president of England's Royal College of Ophthalmologists had a chance to play with the system for a while, telling a British paper that he thinks that long-term trials on the potential effects would be sensible.

Larry Benjamin played Super Street Fighter IV: 3D Edition in a session set up by The Independent. Afterward, he had this to say about the experience: "It's remarkable 3D, but it's fairly dependent on your position. If you're just five degrees off, it doesn't quite work, which is tiring for the eyes... you continually have to readjust to 3D vision and that's making me feel a bit queasy. I think it's fair to warn people they may experience eye strain, double vision or difficulty focusing. I think it'd be sensible to do longer-term trials on it."

I've been able to spend a considerable chunk of time with the 3DS, and I have mixed feelings about The Independent's report. The lede is cute, though completely sensationalistic ("It promises unique 'eye-popping' entertainment, but what it actually delivers is nausea, sore eyes and dizzying headaches."), and it seems as though this was seen as an opportunity to take a few shots at Nintendo. At the same time, I understand the ophthalmologist's concern, too. This guy's probably forgotten more about vision and the human eye than most of us will ever know.

If you hold the 3DS at an off angle, the 3D image completely breaks. A person could try to adjust their focus to compensate, but it's so obviously out of alignment in those instances that the vast majority of players will simply change the handheld's angle. The 3DS' depth slider is a godsend, too. I found the effect to be a little overwhelming at its maximum setting, and adjusting the effect down to about one-third was best for me. I would hope that The Independent explained that feature to players, particularly the 13-year-old boy they cite who played for five minutes then got nauseous and had to quit.

I played on the 3DS for about eight hours on one day, and I didn't get headaches or feel nauseous. I was a little worried about my eyes at the start of the session, but my fears evaporated pretty quickly. Aside from the added illusion of depth, it wasn't any different than looking at any other LCD. Of course, that's just my experience. Do we know if other people will suffer long-term effects from playing too much 3DS? I have no idea. Nintendo doesn't seem to think so. One thing's for sure: We'll be hearing a lot more about this issue in the coming months.

Email the author , or follow on , , , and .

Comments
  • I don't see it being a huge problem, if this thing has really been in development for however many years surely Nintendo would have thought about this at some point in development.

  • No way in hell is some reporter stopping me from playing Ocarina of Time. IN 3-D :D
  • Personally, I think we should wait until it comes out before we come to conclusions.
  • The concerns do seem valid, but I kinda think it may be one of those things were very few people suffer from any kind of long term effects, if at all.

  • Well let me ask this: Why is all this eye strain/nausea business being associated only with the 3DS and not all the other 3D tech that's out there? I think Nintendo kind of started this themselves a while ago with their warning about little kids playing the 3DS. It's not like I'm looking all that forward to the system's 3D or anything, but it seems a bit unfair that the 3DS is the only target for concern when everybody else is trying to push 3D on us as well.
  • Eh, this 3D stuff is getting on my nerves. Personally, I don't care if this system crashes and burns.
  • I'm really hoping that Nintendo put the safety of its customers BEFORE its profit motive. :P
  • He probably doesnt even play games and may be older,my grandpa gets sick looking at my games, such as CoD and those games are'nt even 3D.
  • You make a good point Jeff, but how many kids and teens do you believe would crank the 3d effect down to help their eyes? I know everyone is going to go for max effect cause it's new and they want to get the most out of it. And it will be this kind of stubbornness that will create bad press for the big N after the 3DS's release. Someone who shouldn't even be playing video games is going to have a seizure or something and then the news is going to swoop down on this like a pack of vultures.

    Maybe I'm just being pessimistic, but that's what I think.
  • It is safe to say that you should hear Nintendo advice and play the games on this sistem for at least a few hours daily.

  • I have never owned one of these. Just had a gameboy pocket, color and an sp. old skool lol
  • I'd personally like to see a study done, but not by this guy. they seem to be alittle biased imo, but their concern over a study is justified. No one knows what the long term effects will be, and if 3D tech wants to move forward in the future, this is something that should be thoroughly researched.

    anyways, im still getting a 3DS, so maybe i'll find out for myself.

  • Please, your eyes get tired without the 3D. And if you really feel like your straining your eyes then you can turn the 3D off for a bit.

    Not a big deal.

  • personally. I was excited for this. That was until the NGP got announced. Also, I know somebody who was at E3 and said that the graphics still weren't that impressive. Basically, I'll probably get it, but not now. Also, like other people said Nintendo did this to themselves sadly.
  • I don't think that it will be as big a deal as a lot of people are making it out to be. But on the other hand keeping an eye on it probably isn't a horrible idea. I will be getting a 3DS eventually but I really don't see myself playing with 3D turned on.
  • why didn't turn off the 3d if he was complaining?

  • no sensational media report is gonna stop me, anyway you could just turn the 3D off when you get tired

  • I will volunteer, for science!

  • I feel that it couldn't hurt to look more into the effects the 3dS could have on different people. It should all be done by an unbiased, outside company that has nothing to do with the profits that would be gained from the undoubtedly high sales. Personally, as awesome as the 3DS sounds, I won't be playing it. Because of a medical condition I have that has caused my cerebellum to slip down into my brainstem, I can already tell from what I've read that the eyestrain will cause terrible headaches for me. That really sucks, because Ocarina Of Time in 3D sounds like it would be killer.
  • I'd never buy one, so I'll just sit on the sidelines and laugh.
1 2 3 Next