Switch Lights

The lights are on

What's Happening

Hands-On With Rock Band Network


With absolutely no advance warning, Rock Band Network went live to the public today. We've played around with it this afternoon to give you a full rundown of the exciting new features. The best addition so far? Playable demos.

First off, the new RBN content does not blast you in the face the moment you boot up Rock Band 2. It's simply an extra menu option under the already existing music store. Here's what you get:

Top 10
After buying and playing an RBN song, you now have the opportunity to rate it on a one to five lighter scale. The ten highest-rated tracks will appear here. Since not many people have played around on the service yet, there aren't a whole lot of ratings. This means there are quite a few perfect five ratings at the moment, but the top 10 should become more useful once RBN has been around a little longer. There's also a tab for the 10 newest songs, but again there are 105 new total songs up right now, so this won't be useful right out of the gate.

Harmonix Picks
This appears to be a hand-picked list of 10 featured tracks. Who knows how bands are selected, but if you're interested here are the current picks:

Bif Naked - "Sick"
Flogging Molly - "Requiem for a Dying Song"
Furly - "Icarus' Song"
Stroke 9 - "Little Black Backpack '09"
The Cold Goodnight - "Give"
Lacuna Coil - "Survive"
The Main Drag - "Don't Let Me Down (Slowly)"
The Slip - "Even Rats"
Steve Vai - "Get the Hell Out of Here"
Five Finger Death Punch - "Burn it Down"

Browse

This is where you can really dig in and check out every song that's in RBN.  Sorting categories include: recording artist, note chart author, country of origin, decade of original release, difficulty, music genre, record label, language, and song title. Artist and song title work best if you already know what you want and would like to get there as quickly as possible. Otherwise, going into a different menu for every single letter of the alphabet gets tedious. If you just want to see everything in one place, language is the best place to browse since 104 of the current 105 songs are in English. Once you buy a song, it automatically appears in your main music library with a custom "RBN" logo next to it.

Random Song
The final main menu option is just what it sounds like. You hit this tab and it takes you to any track in the library. I can see it being a fun option for someone with some cash to burn who's looking for something new.

Pricing
All of the songs so far are priced at either $1 or $2. Most of the $1 songs lean in the indie direction while bigger bands go for the higher price. Though this isn't necessarily law. Flogging Molly tracks are only a buck while plenty of bands I hadn't heard of were the full two dollars. Even artists aren't necessarily consistent with their own pricing. The band You Shriek uses both prices, for example. One thing that isn't featured yet is track grouping discounts like song packs and albums. Even though The Main Drag has 11 songs up already, you'll have to buy them all one by one.

Demos!
In addition to have the standard sound clip preview of a track, you can now download playable demos of any song in RBN. Once the demo is downloaded, you back out to quick play to check it out. Once you get about 30 to 40 seconds of play time into the song it abruptly ends. Here you have the option to play it again, switch to a new song, buy the full version of the song, or instantly delete the demo if you don't like it. You actually download the entire song with a lock on it, so if you decide to buy the track it only takes a split second to become available.

Note Charts
For those unfamiliar with the RBN system, song charts are all done by third-party companies or bands themselves. Then they go through a peer review process before they're eventually approved for sale. I bought a handful of songs to see what kind of quality note charts come out the other end. After all, these tracks are competing directly with the professional Harmonix charts we all know and love. As far as I could tell, expert guitar was totally solid on tracks like "Heimdalsgate Like a Promethean Curse" by Of Montreal, "Australia" by The Shins, and "Sequestered in Memphis" by the Hold Steady. Random indie demos seemed above board as well. The take home message: thumbs up on charting so far.

So who's played around with Rock Band Network so far? What's your take on it?

Email the author , or follow on , and .

Comments
  • Rock band sucks, play Guitar Hero

  • Holy *** awesome! There are a ton of tracks I want to go check out, and $1 apiece is reasonable.

    And nice first rmeyer, real insightful there. I don't see Guitar Hero doing anything like this...

  • rmeyer, that is your opinion and no one cares. Rock Band and Guitar Hero both add lots of flavor to the music game genre and the fact that they have both released a handful of games and are both still making games makes it seem like neither sucks because then they would not be selling any.

  • Ehhhhhh....if I was able to at least listen to the whole song, as opposed to playing it, then I would probably check it out. There's just too many problems I have with RBN and all of those bands I've never heard of. (Excluding 2-4 bands.)

  • Bah! Sick of music game that revolve around a guitar! Oh hello Mr. DJ!

  • Rock Band is better b/c it's made by Harmonix. And Harmonix is the best music game developer out there. Period.

  • *** u rmeyer u piece of *** u have no *** taste and gaming so *** urself

  • Already loving this new service. New Jonathan Coulton tracks are up (although they're $2 when his songs in the regular Music Store are $1, so a little strange there).  Also my favorite unlockable song from GH1, Even Rats, is on RBN. The new features are also pretty sweet, and I hope the rating and demo systems someday make their way into the Music Store proper.

    There were a few things that bothered me though:

    1. The RBN tracks don't appear when you use the Rock Band Music Store app, meaning you have to pop the game disc in to browse the song library. This isn't really that big of a deal, but I'm lazy.

    2. My download queue doesn't seem to download when I'm playing Rock Band. So I'll see a song I'm curious about and download the demo, but then I have to back out to the dashboard for it to actually download. Then when that's finished, if I like the song I can buy the full version, but then I have to back out and let it download again, even though all it's doing is unlocking the demo version I already downloaded.

    Other than this, LOVE the service.  It's not every day I turn on my Xbox and see over 100 brand-new Rock Band tracks available for download, so today was a pleasant surprise.

  • I love it so far, would like to see some more bands I know that won't ever get an official Harmonix chart up on the main store like Fozzy or Sevendust and maybe further expansion of a larger bands catalog (Staind for instance) that have a few songs on the main store but probably won't see Harmonix release many more in a timely matter. Apparently Dave Grohl is the only one who gets that type of exposure on the main store.

    Demos need to be expanded to the Main store, my favorite feature of the update. Enjoyed seeing some of the older indy songs from GH1 and GH2 show up.

    The Network is very promising, can't wait to see what comes next down the pipeline.

  • Stroke 9 and Stroke 9 alone tempts me to buy Rock band 2. What can I say, I'm a loyalist.

  • Nice to know that there trying.

  • I am interested in this and I will be checking into this later :D

  • I have a problem with Rockband Network after logging on a few hours ago. All the music is great and I can't wait to see what they have coming down the pipe, but it is ungodly slow. It's to the point that it is excruciating, the preview for one of the Steve Vai songs didn't load in the 15 minutes that I let it sit, yet the Harmonix Music store loaded fine and fast.

  • Rockband and Guitar Hero are both bad, in my opinion.

  • All sounds good.

  • this service rocks.

  • Guitar Hero, rmeyer?  What's that?

    Guitar Hero is dead.  Maybe you mean "Band Hero" or "PC Rock Band rip-off".

  • I haven't but i will tomorrow to busy trophy hunting

  • Flogging Molly, Jonathan Coulton, and Stroke 9 are reason enough for me to dust off the plastic axes.

  • Jeez guys, how about we DON'T turn this into a flame war?  Obvious troll up top is obvious, and we don't need to point that out more than once.

    Anyways, I played around with the RBN for about an hour, and I really liked it.  I've got about 15 song demos, and I plan on getting a lot of full songs.  However, it's still a bit buggy; sometimes when I try to view a song, it'll take me back to the main menu.  Also, the preview quality is less than stellar.  But still, it's neat, and I can't wait to see what's next.

1 2 Next