Now that the Nintendo DS is in the rear-view mirror, we wanted to run down a list of our all-time favorite games for the beloved system. You can find the full, ranked list in the latest issue of Game Informer, but the debate over the list became so heated that it spilled over into a bonus video. Rather than run down our list in numerical order, we decided to let four Game Informer editors pick and defend their favorite game for the system.

Watch the video below as Joe Juba, Dan Ryckert, Bryan Vore, and Kim Wallace play and discuss their favorite games for the Nintendo DS.