BATMAN: ARKHAM ASYLUM ISSUE ON SALE NOW!
GameInformer - The Final Word on Video and Computer Games
Subscribe |  Customer Service |  My Account   
USERNAME   
PASSWORD 
REMEMBER MY ID
Forgot your password? | Register

 PLATFORM: PLAYSTATION 2
SWINGING FOR THE FENCES AGAIN

ith the PlayStation 3 taking center stage, I was a bit worried that Sony would phone in the highly dreaded “this console is dead, so let’s just update the rosters” sequel. MLB 07: The Show may show a lack of creativity in the naming convention, but through a number of innovative enhancements, it turned out to be the most impressive follow-up that Sony has put together so far. All eyes may be looking to the next- generation, but for baseball, you are going to have to turn your gaze toward the PlayStation 2. For hardcore baseball nuts, The Show is the game to get.

Being able to create a player and try out for a spot on the team has always been the main allure of this series. Not only does it create a personal tie to the experience, it makes you appreciate each at bat more than you would in any other game. In this year’s edition, we are seeing exactly how deep this experience can get. In addition to batting, you are now tasked with playing defense and running the bases. Playing the field could be yawn-inducing affair, but thankfully, you never have to wait around for a ball to be hit to you. Like the batting sequences last year, the game automatically fast-forwards to when a ball is hit to you. Knowing when a ball is heading your way may seem cheesy, but this system allows you to get a proper jump on the ball without having the disorientation of the camera switch you see in other baseball games. The fielding itself is incredibly fluid and extremely fun, but the game still makes questionable decisions regarding which animation will be used. This can lead to some grounders getting through the diamond, or a sure out turning into a runner on base.

The batting and pitching battle has also been streamlined to further bring out the realism of the sport. If a pitcher is on fire with a pitch, he will gain more confidence in that specific pitch. Like 2K’s game, catchers are no longer static. They call for specific pitches and locations, and through this, accurately work the arm of individual pitchers. If Johan Santana has you down 0-2, there’s a good chance he’ll make you look stupid with a “12-6” curveball.

On the batting front, you can really tell when you get good wood on the ball or if you are going to dribble it foul. You also have to read the umpire. In any given game you can have one of three different umpire types: one with a tight strike zone, one with a wide zone, and another who calls the game fairly. The online leagues are also pretty slick and allow for a high level of customization and control.

I love the look of 2K Sports’ game on PS3 and Xbox 360, but this game rules the base paths with its remarkable gameplay.

  

ADAM BIESSENER   8.25
I’m impressed. Despite the regrettable lack of an analog swing, The Show delivers the absolute best pitcher/batter faceoffs in video games to date. Umps are stingy with strikes, which forces pitchers to really work for those backdoor on-the-black calls. Protecting the plate on two-strike counts is also much easier, since you can foul off pitches that you can’t afford to take. Some missteps on infield defense and a paucity of analog controls hold this title back from true greatness, but the PS2 won’t see many more releases this entertaining.
8.75
CONCEPT:
The array of improvements lead to the highest level of realism and the most rewarding experience this year
GRAPHICS:
Smooth animations, but details are lacking
SOUND:
The three-man booth (Rex Hudler, Dave Campbell, and Matt Vasgersian) accurately calls the game, and properly recognizes most situations
PLAYABILITY:
Not just a game of batting and pitching. Players must now learn the art of base running and fielding
ENTERTAINMENT:
This is easily the deepest and most satisfying baseball game this year
REPLAY:
High